
138 Out of 140: The Federal Audit That Caught Arkansas Breaking Its Own Child Abuse Rules
Federal auditors checked 140 Arkansas child abuse investigations and found 138 broke the state's own rules. Families were routinely never told how their cases ended, the state's case system has no place to even record a parent, and a report of an 11-year-old's rape disclosure was screened out. Adam breaks down the HHS Inspector General audit and the near-total absence of discipline that followed.

Federal auditors pulled 140 child abuse investigations in Arkansas. They checked each one against the state’s own rules. Not federal guidelines. Not some advocate’s wish list. Arkansas’s own requirements. 138 of them failed.
Two out of 140 got it right. And this is the agency with the power to label a parent, open a case, and start the process that can end with your children taken.
This is the Father’s Advocacy Network podcast. I’m Adam Neuerburg. Today we’re opening a federal audit of the Arkansas Division of Children and Family Services and the Arkansas State Police. It shows investigations that broke the rules in nearly every case checked, families who were never told how their own cases ended, and almost nobody held responsible.
The audit comes from the U.S. Department of Health and Human Services Office of Inspector General. It was issued September 29, 2026, and posted publicly October 2. It covers hotline reports received from October 1, 2023, through September 30, 2024. Auditors found that 138 of 140 sampled investigations, handled by the Division of Children and Family Services and the State Police, did not meet requirements for screening, for risk and safety assessment, or for investigation. Then they projected that sample across the whole year. According to NEA Report and the Mountain Home Observer, auditors estimated that about 20,964 of 21,268 accepted in-home reports failed at least one state requirement. Roughly 99 percent.
If that projection holds, nearly every family Arkansas investigated that year went through an investigation that broke the rules. Every one of those families was told to trust the process. And the inspectors were clear about their standard. If the state’s own files couldn’t show a requirement was met, it counted as a failure. In the words of the audit, as reported by NEA Report, where compliance could not be substantiated, auditors reported noncompliance. That is the same standard agencies hold parents to every day. Didn’t document the class? Didn’t happen. Missed the paperwork? Noncompliant. For once, the agency was measured by its own rules. And it failed.
The hotline wasn’t much better. Of 27,690 reports the state screened out, auditors sampled 70. They found 10 should not have been rejected. The state agreed on nine. Auditors projected that about 3,956 rejected reports, roughly 14 percent, were mishandled. And KATV reported on one of them. A rejected report involving an 11-year-old’s disclosure of rape. It was screened out because staff believed a young child might not understand the word.
So here’s the picture. An agency that drags families through investigations that break its own rules, and at the same time screens out a child’s disclosure of rape. Power everywhere. Accuracy nowhere. And notice who pays for both failures. A child who discloses abuse and gets screened out. A parent who gets investigated under rules nobody followed. The same agency failed both of them. And as you’re about to hear, the same agency answers to almost no one.
For families, the most telling findings are about notice. Who gets told what, and when. According to the Mountain Home Observer’s review of the audit, there was no record that alleged victims were told the outcome in 132 of the 140 sampled cases. Alleged offenders were not notified in 43 cases. And the agency stopped sending outcome notices to parents in 59 cases. If you’re a parent listening right now, think about what that means. You get investigated. Someone comes into your home, talks to your kids, writes things down about you. And then silence. No letter. No finding. No way to challenge it, clear your name, or know whether that record will follow you into a custody case, a job application, or the next hotline call.
A finding nobody tells you about is a finding you can’t fight. It just sits in a file you’ve never seen, waiting for the next time someone pulls your name. And it gets worse. Auditors couldn’t even tell whether parents were interviewed at all. The state’s case management system is called CHRIS. According to the Observer, it has no role for parents. None. So the files could not show whether custodial and noncustodial parents ever gave their side. The inspector general lists this as its own finding. Arkansas could not support that required interviews with alleged victims’ parents were completed.
A system built to investigate families, with no place to record the parents. Mothers and fathers alike, written out of their own cases by design. The documentation gaps keep going. According to NEA Report and the Observer, there was no record that all required interviews were completed in 84 cases. At least one interview was documented late in 127. 32 of 140 investigations closed late. One by more than 200 days. 16 cases had no record of a completed safety assessment. There was no record police were told of severe maltreatment findings in 48 cases. Prosecutors weren’t notified of outcomes in 40.
These aren’t paperwork glitches. Missing interviews, missing safety assessments, parents never told the outcome. Those are due process failures. And they put every family who crosses that hotline at risk of decisions nobody can check.
So who answers for this? In an August 21 letter, Division Director Tiffany Wright and Arkansas State Police Major Jeffrey L. Drew wrote that the division does not dispute most of those findings, according to the Observer. Does not dispute. They know. The state concurred with three of the inspector general’s six recommendations, and only partially concurred with the other three. The inspector general considers one recommendation fulfilled. Five are still open. The state argued the problems point to a need for supervisory oversight and accountability. So let’s look at the accountability. The Observer reported that in October 2025, Wright told a legislative committee that no employee had been disciplined over a case that drew 29 hotline reports.
29 reports. Zero discipline. A March 2026 contractor review of 327 cases led to one firing, one demotion, one written warning and four counseling statements. 327 cases. One person lost their job.
Compare that to what happens to a parent. One missed drug test, one missed visit, and it goes in the court report. And the fixes are crawling. The division began sending unsubstantiated-finding notices to alleged victims on June 4, 2026, with parent notices to follow by mid-September, according to the Observer. The label change in CHRIS, so that parents can even be recorded in the system, has no date. The hotline manual rewrite is on hold until the 2027 legislative session. Ask yourself how long a parent gets to fix a problem on a case plan before the state calls it failure to comply. Now compare that to this. A federal audit, a written admission, and the most basic fix for parents still has no date.
FAN will be watching whether the Arkansas Legislature’s oversight committee holds the second public hearing it promised, and whether any supervisor at the division or the State Police is held responsible.
If you’ve been investigated, in Arkansas or anywhere else, here’s what you can do. This isn’t legal advice. FAN is not a law firm. One. Don’t wait for the agency to tell you how your case ended. This audit shows it may never happen. Ask in writing for the outcome of the investigation, and for any finding made against you. Two. Request your records. Ask for your case file, and ask whether your interview, and the other parent’s, was ever recorded. If it isn’t in the file, it may as well not have happened. Three. Document everything yourself. Every visit, every call, every name, date and time. Get the full name of the investigator and their supervisor. Gather your own evidence: school records, doctor visits, people who know your family. Four. If there’s a finding against you, ask in writing how to appeal it and what the deadline is. Put every request to your attorney in writing, and keep copies. And five. You don’t have to do this alone. Go to fathers advocacy network dot com slash case help.
The full story on the Arkansas audit, with every source we used, including the inspector general’s report, is on our website, at fathers advocacy network dot com. If this made you angry, share it with someone who still believes these investigations follow the rules. 138 out of 140 say otherwise. And follow the show, so you don’t miss the next one. I’m Adam Neuerburg. This is the Father’s Advocacy Network. Let the silenced speak.
- fathersadvocacynetwork.com/stories/arkansas-dcfs-federal-audit-138-of-140-child-abuse-investigations/
- oig.hhs.gov/reports/all/2026/arkansas-failed-to-comply-with-the-immediate-screening-risk-and-safety-assessment-and-investigation-requirements-for-responding-to-reports-of-child-abuse-and-neglect/
- katv.com/news/local/dhhs-arkansas-failed-to-comply-with-child-sexual-abuse-response-requirements
- neareport.com/2026/10/08/arkansas-child-abuse-reports-federal-audit/
- mhobserver.com/federal-audit-cites-mountain-home-case-finds-arkansas-failed-to-follow-rules-in-138-of-140-child-abuse-investigations/
- arkansasadvocate.com/2026/10/07/federal-audit-says-arkansas-mishandled-reports-of-child-abuse-and-neglect/
Father’s Advocacy Network is not a law firm. Nothing in this episode is legal advice.









