21 Monroe County Mothers Say Seeking Help Triggered CPS Investigations, HOPE585 Report Finds

Monroe County women told HOPE585 that asking for help with housing, child care or mental health led to CPS investigations; most county reports go unfounded.
Monroe County Office Building on Main Street in Rochester, New York
Photo: Warren LeMay / Wikimedia Commons, CC BY-SA 2.0

Rochester, New York — Women in Monroe County who asked therapists, schools and agencies for help with housing, child care or mental health said those requests led to Child Protective Services investigations instead, according to a report released Oct. 29 by the Rochester nonprofit HOPE585.

The report, “Voices of Experience: Findings from Focus Groups with Women Impacted by the Child Welfare System,” draws on four focus groups with 21 Monroe County women who have been through the county’s child welfare system. The groups were held in March and April, the Rochester Beacon reported.

What the women described

Participants said they avoided schools, doctors, therapists and community agencies because they feared that asking for help would trigger a CPS investigation or the loss of their children, according to the Rochester Beacon. Unmet needs such as housing, mental health care and child care were sometimes treated as neglect rather than as requests for help.

Women said they felt presumed guilty during investigations, received little information about their rights and feared retaliation if they advocated for themselves, according to a summary of the report published by the Minority Reporter. Some said their words were distorted or used against them, and many were confused about family court, News10NBC reported.

There has to be a place where you can ask for help without it being used against you.

Focus group participant, HOPE585 report, via the Minority Reporter

Several participants said schools and service providers were not equipped to support children with autism or complex behavioral needs, and that those struggles sometimes became child welfare cases. They described lasting effects including hypervigilance, shame and fear of future separation from their children.

The county numbers behind the report

Monroe County CPS received 6,434 reports of suspected child abuse or neglect in 2025, or 43 per 1,000 children, the Rochester Beacon reported. Of the reports determined as of March 20, about 75% were unfounded.

The FAN Podcast · New episodes every Tuesday & Friday

The cases they buried, read out loud.

New
Episode 20 · Nov 17 · 11 min

138 Out of 140: The Federal Audit That Caught Arkansas Breaking Its Own Child Abuse Rules

Federal auditors checked 140 Arkansas child abuse investigations and found 138 broke the state's own rules. Families were routinely never told how their cases ended, the state's case system has no place to even…

Episode 20 · Nov 17, 2026 · 10:58
0:0010:58

News10NBC reported that 76% of Monroe County CPS investigations close without a finding of child maltreatment, a figure the Minority Reporter attributed to earlier HOPE585 research. The station also reported that about 915 unfounded investigations are open on any given day and that the county’s rate of CPS investigations is 37% higher than New York City’s. Black children in the county were 5.5 times more likely, and Hispanic children 3.5 times more likely, than white children to enter foster care.

Where the system failed

HOPE585 Executive Director Ashley Cross, a co-author of the report, told the Rochester Beacon that state law leaves mandated reporters little room for judgment and that the statutory definition of neglect is broad. Co-author Brandy Shaw, the group’s manager of advocacy and policy, said the concern is not cases with obvious bruises or evident harm, but situations such as a student arriving in the same clothes.

Many of these families have, in fact, not done anything wrong.

Ashley Cross, executive director, HOPE585, to the Rochester Beacon

Cross told News10NBC that participants understood CPS must investigate when a report is screened in. Their objection, she said, was to how investigations were carried out.

What the report recommends

The report calls for shifting from surveillance-based intervention to community-based prevention and family support, bringing people with lived experience into child welfare leadership, increasing transparency and accountability, and adopting trauma-informed practices. In an accompanying legislative brief, HOPE585 urges New York to advance parental rights notification legislation, known as “Family Miranda,” which would give parents verbal and written information about their rights at the first point of contact, the Rochester Beacon reported.

News10NBC said it requested comment from Monroe County and did not receive a response.

When three out of four reports end without a finding, the cost of an investigation falls on families who did nothing wrong. The women in this report were not asking for less accountability, as Cross put it in announcing the findings. They asked to be told their rights and not to be punished for seeking help. FAN’s guide to what to expect in a CPS investigation explains the rights parents have when a caseworker knocks.

Key facts

  • HOPE585 released “Voices of Experience” on Oct. 29, 2026, based on four focus groups with 21 Monroe County women.
  • Women said seeking help with housing, child care or mental health led to CPS investigations.
  • Monroe County CPS received 6,434 reports in 2025; about 75% of those determined by March 20 were unfounded.
  • Earlier HOPE585 research found 76% of county CPS investigations close without a maltreatment finding.
  • Black children were 5.5 times and Hispanic children 3.5 times as likely as white children to enter foster care.
  • HOPE585 urges a “Family Miranda” law requiring parents be told their rights at first contact.
  • Monroe County did not respond to News10NBC’s request for comment.

Sources

What you can do

Don't just read it. Act on it.

Lawmakers fund and oversee this system. Tell New York lawmakers what happened here.

Open in my email

Get an email when this case has a new development: charges, court dates, verdicts, settlements. Only about this case; unsubscribe anytime.

Lived through something like this? Your case could be the next one we document.

Read next

This story exists because families spoke up.

Father’s Advocacy Network is a nonprofit newsroom. We don’t take money from the agencies we cover. Help us keep exposing what happens behind closed doors.

About Father’s Advocacy Network. We investigate failures inside CPS, foster care, adoption and family court — and stand with parents fighting to bring their children home. Have a correction or a tip? Contact our newsroom.

Most Read

Is this happening to your family?

Tell us your story — confidentially. Every case we cover starts with a parent speaking up.

Join the conversation

Have something to add? Create a free account or log in to comment. Accounts keep the discussion real and free of bots.

Create free accountLog in

Scroll to Top