Utah Audit: DCFS Missed Deadlines in 3,200 Cases; Death Reviews Cleared It 3 Years

A Utah legislative audit found DCFS missed face-to-face deadlines in 3,200 investigations and its child death reviews cleared the agency for three years despite violations.
Utah State Capitol in Salt Lake City
Photo: Farragutful / Wikimedia Commons, CC BY-SA 4.0

Salt Lake City, Utah — Utah’s Division of Child and Family Services missed the deadline to see a child face to face in just over 3,200 abuse and neglect investigations in fiscal year 2025, and its internal reviews of child deaths reported no policy violations for three straight years even when auditors found significant ones, according to a legislative audit.

The Office of the Legislative Auditor General released the report, No. 2026-03, in January. Auditors presented it to the Legislative Audit Subcommittee on Jan. 30, 2026. The Department of Health and Human Services, which oversees DCFS, concurred with all eight recommendations.

What the audit found

Auditors reviewed Child Protective Services investigations from fiscal year 2025. Caseworkers missed priority deadlines for first contact with a child in 13.7% of cases. The rate varied sharply by office, from 3% in Blanding to 27% in Orem.

Required safety assessments were not completed or uploaded on time in more than 7,800 cases. Late rates ranged from 13% in the Bountiful office to 76% in Richfield. In more than 4,600 closed cases, supervisors never approved extensions the cases needed. That rate ranged from 17% in Salem to 90% in Heber.

The FAN Podcast · New episodes every Tuesday & Friday

The cases they buried, read out loud.

New
Episode 19 · Nov 13 · 12 min

The Civil Death Penalty: How the State Terminates Parental Rights, and How Parents Fight Back

About 1 in 100 American children will see a parent's rights terminated by age 18, and on one day in 2025, 46,308 children whose parents' rights were already cut off were still waiting in…

Episode 19 · Nov 13, 2026 · 12:09
0:0012:09

The auditors recommended that senior leadership set performance targets for caseworkers and supervisors, with procedures for when staff fall short, and that supervisors hold caseworkers to the division’s own practice guidelines.

Death reviews that found nothing

Utah reviews the deaths of children who received child welfare services. In 2018, 9 of 23 fatality review reports, or 39%, found the division had not followed policy. In 2023, 2024 and 2025, the share was zero.

Auditors found significant policy violations in some of the cases that the reviews had cleared. They also found that four fatality reports from fiscal years 2022 through 2025 required a formal response from the department, and the department provided none for three of them.

troubling deficiencies that starve the oversight process

Utah Office of the Legislative Auditor General, Report No. 2026-03

The reports went to the Child Welfare Legislative Oversight Panel, five lawmakers who had been told for three years that the division followed policy in every case, Utah News Dispatch reported. Auditors also found the reports were redacted more heavily than necessary.

Where the system failed

The audit describes a review process that stopped asking hard questions. Division leaders told auditors the old reviews singled out individual caseworkers for harsh criticism instead of drawing broader lessons. The audit said the current process delivers neither.

Senate Minority Leader Luz Escamilla, D-Salt Lake City, who sits on the oversight panel, told agency officials the situation “kind of hurts when you’re trying to build a relationship of working closely with the executive branch,” according to Utah News Dispatch.

Carrie Bambrough, who directs the department’s Division of Continuous Quality and Improvement, said the department agrees it should identify both systemic and case-specific problems.

What happened next

Auditors recommended that the Legislature consider giving oversight panel members unredacted access to fatality reports. Rep. Cheryl Acton, R-West Jordan, sponsored House Bill 434, which would have limited redactions in those reports to a child’s last name and address.

The bill never received a recorded vote. Legislative records show the House struck its enacting clause and filed it on March 6, 2026.

The wider pattern

Families under investigation are held to strict deadlines and every allegation is written down. This audit shows the agency doing the investigating was allowed to grade its own work, and when children died, the grade was always a pass. Oversight that depends on the agency’s own redacted summaries is not oversight. Parents facing an investigation can read FAN’s guide to how CPS investigations work.

Key facts

  • Report No. 2026-03 from Utah’s Office of the Legislative Auditor General was presented Jan. 30, 2026.
  • DCFS missed priority face-to-face deadlines in just over 3,200 FY2025 investigations (13.7%).
  • Safety assessments were late in more than 7,800 cases; office rates ran from 13% to 76%.
  • More than 4,600 closed cases lacked a needed supervisor-approved extension.
  • Fatality reviews found policy violations in 39% of 2018 reports and 0% in 2023 through 2025, though auditors found significant violations.
  • The department gave no required response on three of four fatality reports, FY2022 to FY2025.
  • HB 434, limiting redactions for the legislative oversight panel, died March 6, 2026.

Sources

What you can do

Don't just read it. Act on it.

Lawmakers fund and oversee this system. Tell Utah lawmakers what happened here.

Open in my email

Get an email when this case has a new development: charges, court dates, verdicts, settlements. Only about this case; unsubscribe anytime.

Lived through something like this? Your case could be the next one we document.

Read next

This story exists because families spoke up.

Father’s Advocacy Network is a nonprofit newsroom. We don’t take money from the agencies we cover. Help us keep exposing what happens behind closed doors.

About Father’s Advocacy Network. We investigate failures inside CPS, foster care, adoption and family court — and stand with parents fighting to bring their children home. Have a correction or a tip? Contact our newsroom.

Most Read

Is this happening to your family?

Tell us your story — confidentially. Every case we cover starts with a parent speaking up.

Join the conversation

Have something to add? Create a free account or log in to comment. Accounts keep the discussion real and free of bots.

Create free accountLog in

Scroll to Top