Columbus Foster Mother Gets 29 Years to Life in Killing of Boy, 5, Left in Storm Drain

Pammy Maye, who got custody of a 5-year-old after Franklin County Children Services became involved, was sentenced to 29 years to life for killing him in 2024.
Franklin County Courthouse in Columbus, Ohio
Photo: Ɱ / Wikimedia Commons, CC BY-SA 4.0
9 min read

Columbus, Ohio — A Columbus woman who took custody of a 5-year-old boy after Franklin County Children Services became involved in his life was sentenced Thursday to 29 years to life in prison for killing him and leaving his body in a storm drain in February 2024, according to WOSU Public Media and Us Weekly.

Franklin County Common Pleas Judge Mark Serrott imposed the sentence on Pammy Maye on Nov. 19, nine days after a jury found her guilty on all counts. She was convicted of aggravated murder, tampering with evidence and abuse of a corpse. The boy’s biological family had asked for life without parole, WOSU reported. Maye will be 80 before she is eligible for parole.

FAN is not naming the child.

What happened in February 2024

Maye told detectives she suffocated the boy with a trash bag, according to Us Weekly’s account of the case. Prosecutors said she killed him after he brought a granola bar and peanut butter crackers to his bed.

Around 3 a.m. on Feb. 14, 2024, Maye told her husband the boy was dead and left in a Jeep, Us Weekly reported. Her husband called 911 when he could not find the child. Police found the Jeep in a parking lot in Brooklyn, Ohio, a Cleveland suburb, and Maye was found there the next evening. She confessed and told police where to find the body, according to WOSU. Searchers found the boy two days later in a sewer drain in Franklin Township.

At trial, the jury rejected a plea of not guilty by reason of insanity. Reports cited at trial said Maye has bipolar disorder and major depression and that she faked some symptoms, WOSU reported. She had been found competent to stand trial.

I have seen a lot in 47 years as a lawyer.

Judge Mark Serrott, Franklin County Common Pleas Court, as reported by WOSU

Maye had several outbursts at the sentencing hearing, and Serrott removed her from the courtroom at one point, WOSU reported. Her lawyer, Sam Shamansky, had argued she belonged in a mental institution rather than prison, according to Us Weekly.

Read nextNew Mexico AG Sues CYFD Over Secrecy as Report Counts 7 Child Deaths in State Custody

How the boy came to live with her

Franklin County Children Services substantiated a report of physical abuse and neglect involving the boy in March 2022, 10TV reported in 2024. His maternal grandparents took him in, then told 10TV they were struggling. They said Maye was a longtime family friend they trusted to help raise him. The family had not seen the boy since July 2023, not long after Maye and her husband received legal custody, 10TV reported.

At the time, agency spokesperson Scott Varner said he could not discuss the case but that “the agency does home studies, background checks and interviews before placing a child with a family friend,” according to 10TV. At Maye’s 2024 arraignment, a prosecutor said she had a history of bipolar disorder and schizophrenia and had shown possessive and controlling behavior, 10TV reported. She had no criminal history.

The agency has not publicly said what its home study found about Maye’s mental health or what contact caseworkers had with the household after custody was transferred. FAN found no public review of the placement.

Where the system failed

Once the boy was placed with a family friend, his safety depended on how carefully Children Services had vetted the home and whether anyone kept checking on him. Seven months after his family last saw him, he was dead. A conviction answers who killed him. It does not answer what the agency knew when it approved the arrangement.

Ohio’s child welfare system has repeatedly faced questions about whether caseworkers actually see the children they are responsible for. FAN reported this month that a Muskingum County caseworker who faked client meetings was sentenced to 6½ years, and that a family sued Lucas County Children Services after an 11-year-old left his group home and was killed. In Philadelphia, a foster mother was charged with murder even though a state panel had said she should never foster again.

When an agency takes responsibility for a child and hands him to someone else, it owes the public an account of how that choice was made. Families navigating a case can read FAN’s guide to how CPS investigations work.

What’s next

Maye will serve her sentence in state prison. Franklin County Children Services has not released any review of the placement.

Key facts

  • Pammy Maye was sentenced Nov. 19, 2026, to 29 years to life by Franklin County Common Pleas Judge Mark Serrott.
  • A jury convicted her Nov. 10 of aggravated murder, tampering with evidence and abuse of a corpse.
  • The 5-year-old was killed in February 2024 and found in a sewer drain in Franklin Township.
  • Franklin County Children Services substantiated an abuse and neglect report involving the boy in March 2022.
  • Maye, a family friend, and her husband received legal custody in 2023, shortly before July, 10TV reported.
  • A prosecutor said at her 2024 arraignment that she had a history of bipolar disorder and schizophrenia.

Sources

This case is part of FAN’s Deaths in Care tracker, our running record of cases like it across the country.

What you can do

Don't just read it. Act on it.

Lawmakers fund and oversee this system. Tell Ohio lawmakers what happened here.

Open in my email

Get an email when this case has a new development: charges, court dates, verdicts, settlements. Only about this case; unsubscribe anytime.

Lived through something like this? Your case could be the next one we document.

Keep reading
The FAN Briefing

Don’t miss the next one.

Every Monday: the week’s CPS and foster care investigations, court rulings and what families can do. Plus alerts when we report on a case you follow.

Free. Unsubscribe anytime. See our Privacy Policy.

This story exists because families spoke up.

Father’s Advocacy Network is a nonprofit newsroom. We don’t take money from the agencies we cover. Help us keep exposing what happens behind closed doors.

About Father’s Advocacy Network. We investigate failures inside CPS, foster care, adoption and family court — and stand with parents fighting to bring their children home. Have a correction or a tip? Contact our newsroom.

Most Read

Is this happening to your family?

Tell us your story — confidentially. Every case we cover starts with a parent speaking up.

Join the conversation

Have something to add? Create a free account or log in to comment. Accounts keep the discussion real and free of bots.

Create free accountLog in

Scroll to Top