From the archive: This story covers a federal audit released in November 2024. FAN is adding past findings to its public record; the latest available information is under “Where it stands now.”
Augusta, Maine — Maine’s child protective agency followed every federal and state requirement in only 6 of 100 child abuse and neglect reports that federal auditors sampled, and in 92 of them it did not send parents and caregivers the required written notice by certified mail within 10 days, the U.S. Department of Health and Human Services Office of Inspector General found in a report issued Nov. 7, 2024.
Projected across the 10,762 reports the Office of Child and Family Services screened in for investigation from Oct. 1, 2021, through Sept. 30, 2022, the OIG estimated that 10,138 reports, or 94%, failed at least one requirement for screening, safety and risk assessment or investigation. The audit, report A-01-23-02500, was the first in an OIG series on how states respond to abuse reports. The OIG said it chose Maine in part because the state’s Child Welfare Ombudsman had already identified substantial problems.
What the auditors found
Auditors reviewed 100 screened-in family reports, stratified by the safety decision caseworkers had made. In the sample, the report found:
- 92 reports where the required written notification letter was not sent by certified mail within 10 days.
- 59 reports where the safety assessment was not completed within 72 hours: 58 were late and one was never documented.
- 44 investigations not completed within 35 days.
- 17 reports where initial interviews were not completed or documented within the required response time.
- 9 risk assessments that were late or undocumented, and 8 safety plans not documented as completed and signed.
- 7 screened-in reports that were never assigned a response time.
Failure to comply with requirements places the children’s health and safety at risk.
HHS Office of Inspector General, report A-01-23-02500
Why it happened
The OIG found that caseworkers had not been trained on some requirements and did not understand others. Supervisors did not review or approve caseworkers’ documentation of interviews with children and adults, and agency policy did not require them to. Supervisors kept handwritten notes and entered safety decisions late. The policy did not require supervisors to monitor reports of overdue investigations on any regular schedule, and written procedures did not explain how a caseworker should override a screened-out report. The move to the state’s new case system, Katahdin, contributed to delays and lost paperwork, the report said.
Read nextMaine Caseworker Sues DHHS, Says He Was Disciplined for Refusing to Change Abuse Finding
On the letters to parents, the OIG reported that agency officials “were unaware” that policy required written notice to every parent or caregiver regardless of the investigation’s outcome.
Where the system failed
The notice letter is how a parent learns what the agency decided about them and what they can do about it. Without it, a parent may never know a finding was entered, may miss the window to challenge it, and may first learn of it much later. In 92 of 100 sampled cases, Maine did not meet that requirement. The failures cut both ways: children waited past deadlines for safety checks, and parents were left out of decisions that could follow them for years. Neither problem is about money. Both are about supervision, written rules and someone checking the file.
Other federal audits FAN has reported found similar failures elsewhere: Iowa skipped required parent notices, and Arkansas mishandled 138 of 140 investigations. In Maine, FAN has reported on a Maine caseworker who says he was disciplined for refusing to change an abuse finding. Parents who believe a finding was made without notice can use FAN’s guide to CPS investigations to learn what records to request.
Where it stands now
Maine concurred with all five OIG recommendations: more caseworker and supervisor training, and written policies on supervisor review of interviews, weekly monitoring of overdue investigations, response-time overrides and keeping proof in Katahdin that notification letters were sent. In its response, the state said the cases dated from 2021 and 2022 and that significant changes had been made since, including a supervision framework, new training supervisor positions, a desk-level procedure for intake overrides and a planned Katahdin upgrade to generate and track notification letters. The OIG’s report page lists all five recommendations as closed and implemented.
Key facts
- Report: HHS OIG, A-01-23-02500, issued Nov. 7, 2024, covering Oct. 1, 2021, to Sept. 30, 2022.
- Only 6 of 100 sampled screened-in reports met every requirement.
- The OIG estimated 10,138 of 10,762 reports, or 94%, were noncompliant.
- 92 sampled reports lacked a notification letter sent by certified mail within 10 days.
- 59 safety assessments missed the 72-hour deadline; 44 investigations ran past 35 days.
- Maine concurred with all five recommendations; the OIG lists them as implemented.
Sources
- HHS Office of Inspector General — Maine Did Not Comply With Screening, Assessment, and Investigation Requirements for Responding to Reports of Child Abuse and Neglect, A-01-23-02500 (2024-11-07)
- HHS Office of Inspector General — Report page and recommendation status, A-01-23-02500 (2024-11-07)
Don't just read it. Act on it.
Lawmakers fund and oversee this system. Tell Maine lawmakers what happened here.
Get an email when this case has a new development: charges, court dates, verdicts, settlements. Only about this case; unsubscribe anytime.
Lived through something like this? Your case could be the next one we document.
Don’t miss the next one.
Every Monday: the week’s CPS and foster care investigations, court rulings and what families can do. Plus alerts when we report on a case you follow.
Free. Unsubscribe anytime. See our Privacy Policy.
The cases they buried, read out loud.
NewThe Guardian ad Litem: The Most Powerful Voice in Your Case Answers to Almost No One
A guardian ad litem's recommendation is, according to research National CASA/GAL itself cites, nearly always accepted by judges. Yet some courts give GALs absolute immunity, most state ombudsman offices won't review them, and in…



















