Riverside, California — A Riverside County social worker took 18 days to respond to a 2024 abuse report about the Haro household, recorded no prior abuse investigations when records showed at least two, and scored the home “low risk,” according to a lawsuit filed against the county’s Department of Public Social Services.
About a year later, the family’s 7-month-old son was dead. His father, Jake Haro, had a prior felony conviction for willful child cruelty. The suit was filed in late July in Riverside County Superior Court on behalf of the infant’s 3-year-old sister, the Los Angeles Times reported.
What the lawsuit alleges
The complaint says DPSS failed to properly investigate a June 2024 hotline report about the Haro home. The report required a response within 10 days, but a social worker did not visit for 18 days, according to the suit.
In her risk assessment, the social worker allegedly recorded zero prior abuse investigations and wrote that Jake Haro had never physically injured a child. The household was scored low risk, and the county did not open a case. The report also noted a gun found in Rebecca Haro’s purse that violated Jake Haro’s probation. The complaint says the weapon was “fully accessible to the children.”
The cases they buried, read out loud.
New138 Out of 140: The Federal Audit That Caught Arkansas Breaking Its Own Child Abuse Rules
Federal auditors checked 140 Arkansas child abuse investigations and found 138 broke the state's own rules. Families were routinely never told how their cases ended, the state's case system has no place to even…

Attorney Roger Booth argues a proper assessment would have produced a high-risk designation and more court oversight, NBC Palm Springs reported. The suit says the surviving sister is significantly behind developmentally, cannot speak or use a spoon, and suffers from a fear of men, crying spells and insomnia.
Read nextRiverside County, ChildNet Pay $13.5M to Six Turpin Siblings Abused in Foster Care
knew as well as anyone that Jake Haro was a very dangerous person.
Roger Booth, attorney for the plaintiff, describing DPSS to the Los Angeles Times
The record the county had
In 2018, Jake Haro and his then-wife were reported for abusing their 2-month-old daughter. A medical assessment found a brain bleed, a skull fracture, shaken baby syndrome and multiple rib fractures, and the girl was left quadriplegic and blind, the Times reported. A juvenile court terminated both parents’ rights to their three children, and Jake Haro was convicted of felony willful child cruelty.
The 7-month-old was reported missing in August 2025, and his parents initially claimed he had been kidnapped. He died of his injuries, and his body has never been found. Jake Haro pleaded guilty to second-degree murder, assault of a child under 8 and false reporting, and was sentenced in November 2025 to 25 years to life. Rebecca Haro pleaded guilty to felony child abuse causing great bodily injury with an involuntary manslaughter enhancement and was sentenced in May 2026 to 12 years and eight months.
Where the system failed
The county’s own records held the 2018 case that ended in terminated parental rights, and the father had a child-cruelty conviction. The lawsuit alleges that information never made it into the assessment that decided whether anyone would check on the children again. A risk score is only as accurate as the history entered into it.
What’s next
A DPSS spokesperson told the Times the county had not yet received the suit and takes child abuse allegations seriously. The allegations have not been tested in court.
Families who face CPS often see the opposite problem: thin or old allegations treated as grounds for removal. This case shows the same agencies can miss a documented record of serious injury when it sits in their own files. Accountability for how investigations are run, and what gets recorded, is the subject of FAN’s guide to the CPS investigation process.
Key facts
- The suit was filed in Riverside County Superior Court against the Department of Public Social Services on behalf of the infant’s 3-year-old sister.
- A June 2024 hotline report required a response within 10 days; the suit says a social worker took 18.
- The assessment allegedly recorded zero prior investigations; records show at least two.
- The home was scored low risk and no case was opened.
- Jake Haro had a prior felony child-cruelty conviction from a 2018 case; his rights to three children were terminated.
- Jake Haro was sentenced to 25 years to life in November 2025; Rebecca Haro to 12 years, eight months in May 2026.
Sources
- Los Angeles Times (via AOL) — Riverside County failed to act on reported abuse before baby Emmanuel’s death, suit alleges (2026-08-01)
- NBC Palm Springs — Lawsuit claims Riverside County missed opportunities to protect baby Emmanuel Haro (2026-08-14)
Don’t miss the next one.
Every Monday: the week’s CPS and foster care investigations, court rulings and what families can do. Plus alerts when we report on a case you follow.
Free. Unsubscribe anytime. See our Privacy Policy.
Related Coverage
CaliforniaRiverside County to Pay $4.2M After Ignoring Warnings About Foster PlacementNov 6, 2026
CaliforniaRiverside County Pays $4.2M; Foster Siblings Say Social Workers Hid Boy’s Abuse HistoryOct 18, 2026
CaliforniaRiverside Foster Parent Who Fostered About 90 Children Charged With Sexual AbuseOct 14, 2026
ArizonaArizona DCS Got 19 Abuse Reports on Girl, 10, Before Her Death, Mother’s Lawsuit SaysNov 13, 2026Don't just read it. Act on it.
Lawmakers fund and oversee this system. Tell California lawmakers what happened here.
Get an email when this case has a new development: charges, court dates, verdicts, settlements. Only about this case; unsubscribe anytime.
Lived through something like this? Your case could be the next one we document.
ABUSE IN CAREUp nextRiverside County, ChildNet Pay $13.5M to Six Turpin Siblings Abused in Foster CareRiverside County and foster agency ChildNet agreed to pay $13.5 million to six Turpin siblings who were placed with foster parents later convicted of abusing them.
Nov 18, 2026
From the Archive: Oklahoma DA Says DHS Bypassed Police on Up to 2,143 Child Abuse ReportsNov 18, 2026
LAWSUITFrom the Archive: NH Paid $2.25M After Suit Cited 17 Reports on Harmony MontgomeryNov 18, 2026
ABUSE IN CARESouth Carolina Sheriff Reopened Second Chance Abuse InvestigationNov 17, 2026

















