Goochland, Virginia — Months before Virginia revoked the license of Hallmark Youthcare’s youth psychiatric facility, the state’s Children’s Ombudsman and a county social services director warned the state’s licensing chief that the facility was obstructing child abuse investigations, and records show no follow-up response from her, WTVR CBS 6 reported Nov. 6.
The warnings
In April, Kimberly Jefferson, director of Goochland County Social Services, wrote to Jae Benz, head of licensing at the Virginia Department of Behavioral Health and Developmental Services (DBHDS). Jefferson said Hallmark Youthcare had put up barriers to child abuse investigations for nearly a year, requiring investigators to obtain administrative subpoenas and fill out record-request forms. Her letter said the requirements caused critical delays, according to CBS 6.
In May, Virginia Children’s Ombudsman Eric Reynolds emailed Benz that Hallmark appeared to be putting up “procedural roadblocks” for Child Protective Services. Benz replied that she would respond later that day. The records DBHDS provided to CBS 6 contain no later response.
About three weeks after that, Rebecca Vinroot of the Virginia Department of Social Services contacted Benz because Jefferson still had not heard back. Vinroot relayed that Hallmark had delayed documents and demanded another administrative subpoena. Benz wrote back that she was checking into it.
The cases they buried, read out loud.
NewThe Civil Death Penalty: How the State Terminates Parental Rights, and How Parents Fight Back
About 1 in 100 American children will see a parent's rights terminated by age 18, and on one day in 2025, 46,308 children whose parents' rights were already cut off were still waiting in…

CBS 6 reported that the records include no further response from Benz. DBHDS confirmed it did not directly respond to Jefferson’s letter, but said that should not be read as inaction and that it was reviewing or investigating the underlying cases.
What happened next
In early July, more than a dozen children ran away from the Goochland facility over two days. WWBT reported that five children escaped on July 6, and that two of them reached the Virginia Beach area before they were found. In all, 13 children escaped, the station reported.
In late July, the disAbility Law Center of Virginia sued the facility, alleging staff physically blocked its employees from entering and ignored follow-up requests to visit or interview patients, according to WWBT. The station also cited a letter documenting several times staff missed required checks, and reported that children were caught in sexual activity during periods when no one was watching them.
DBHDS revoked Hallmark Youthcare’s license on Aug. 17, citing at least 27 violations, Becker’s Behavioral Health reported. Medicaid payments to Hallmark had risen from nearly $7 million to nearly $15 million a year since 2022, according to CBS 6. Hallmark said the revocation would remove 102 beds, disagreed with the decision and said it was evaluating options, including an appeal.
The governor’s response
Gov. Abigail Spanberger told CBS 6 in August that her administration was still working to understand what happened and described a full and comprehensive audit. She said the state’s response was not significant enough.
I commit to you that we will provide clear information and an accounting of what we uncover
Gov. Abigail Spanberger, to WTVR CBS 6
The administration told CBS 6 it could not yet answer questions about what happened after the emails. The station said its investigation is continuing.
Why it matters
Child abuse investigations exist so that someone outside a licensed facility can check on the children inside it. Here, a county agency and the state’s own ombudsman both raised the alarm in writing, and the official with power over the license did not answer them before children ran from the building. That is a failure of accountability, not of information. Parents who have been on the receiving end of a CPS investigation know how quickly the system can act when it wants to; the same urgency was missing when the subject was a licensed provider. Read more about how CPS investigations are supposed to work.
Key facts
- Goochland County Social Services Director Kimberly Jefferson warned DBHDS licensing head Jae Benz in April that Hallmark Youthcare was blocking abuse investigations.
- Children’s Ombudsman Eric Reynolds flagged “procedural roadblocks” to Benz in May.
- Records provided to CBS 6 show no follow-up response from Benz after brief replies.
- Thirteen children escaped the facility in July, WWBT reported.
- DBHDS revoked Hallmark’s license Aug. 17, citing at least 27 violations.
- Medicaid payments to Hallmark rose from nearly $7 million to nearly $15 million a year since 2022.
- Gov. Abigail Spanberger promised an accounting; the administration has not yet answered CBS 6’s questions.
Sources
- WTVR CBS 6 — Children’s Ombudsman warned of CPS ‘roadblocks’ at youth psych facility. What happened next? (2026-11-06)
- WTVR CBS 6 — Spanberger administration revokes Virginia youth psych facility’s license, calls system ‘broken’ (2026-08-19)
- WWBT 12 On Your Side — Gov. Spanberger revokes license for Hallmark Youthcare facility (2026-08-19)
- Becker’s Behavioral Health — Virginia revokes psychiatric facility’s license, citing at least 27 violations (2026-08-25)
Don't just read it. Act on it.
Lawmakers fund and oversee this system. Tell Virginia lawmakers what happened here.
Get an email when this case has a new development: charges, court dates, verdicts, settlements. Only about this case; unsubscribe anytime.
Lived through something like this? Your case could be the next one we document.
ARMED RAIDUp nextArmed CPS Raid in Loudoun County: Family Claims Newborn Was Taken Without Charges or Due ProcessA Navy veteran and his wife say Loudoun County CPS and armed deputies took their one-month-old daughter in March 2025 without a warrant; he filed a federal civil…
Apr 14, 2025
LAWSUITJudge Lets Suit Proceed Over North Carolina Confining Foster Children in Psychiatric FacilitiesNov 14, 2026
Appeals Court Revives West Virginia Foster Care Class Action; State Asks Supreme Court to ActNov 14, 2026
Utah Revokes Provo Canyon School Licenses, Citing Pain-Compliance Tactics and HumiliationNov 13, 2026


















