Ep. 21: The Guardian ad Litem: The Most Powerful Voice in Your Case Answers to Almost No One

Father’s Advocacy Network podcast cover
Episode 21 · Nov 20, 2026 · 11 min listen

The Guardian ad Litem: The Most Powerful Voice in Your Case Answers to Almost No One

A guardian ad litem's recommendation is, according to research National CASA/GAL itself cites, nearly always accepted by judges. Yet some courts give GALs absolute immunity, most state ombudsman offices won't review them, and in 23 states parents can be ordered to pay for them. Adam exposes how the role really works and walks through every way parents can push back when a GAL gets it wrong.

Episode 21 · Nov 20, 2026 · 10:49
0:0010:49
Share this episode

Someone facing CPS right now needs to hear this.

In this episode
Transcript

There is one person in a CPS or custody case whose opinion can decide where your child lives. They’re not the judge. They’re not your lawyer. Sometimes they’re not a lawyer at all. According to research cited by National CASA GAL itself, their recommendations are nearly always accepted by judges. In some courts, they have absolute immunity from lawsuits. Most state oversight offices say they can’t review them. And in 23 states, the court can order you to pay for them. The person writing a report about your parenting may be sending you the bill.

This is the Father’s Advocacy Network podcast. I’m Adam Neuerburg. Today we’re exposing the guardian ad litem, the GAL. What they’re supposed to do, how much power they really have, how little anyone checks them, and what you can do when one gets it wrong.

A guardian ad litem is a person the court appoints to look out for a child’s best interests. They investigate, they write a report, and they recommend what the judge should do. In CPS cases, the GAL is required. Under the federal child abuse law known as CAPTA, states that take the money must appoint a trained GAL in every abuse or neglect case that goes to court. The law says that person may be an attorney or a court appointed special advocate, or both. Notice that. May be an attorney, or may be a volunteer. According to the Child Welfare Information Gateway, about 41 states, plus D.C. and the territories, provide for a GAL to represent a child’s best interests in abuse and neglect cases. Only 16 require that GAL to be a lawyer. The volunteers are called CASAs. In North Carolina, for example, volunteers need 30 hours of training. Then they write court reports and testify, in cases that can decide whether a family stays together.

And the program is huge. According to National CASA GAL, about 79,000 volunteers served 214,000 children in 2024, through 890 programs in 48 states and D.C. Here’s the part every parent needs to hear. The GAL is not necessarily your child’s lawyer. And the GAL is never your lawyer. Best interest is one adult’s opinion about your child. That opinion can rest on a handful of visits and the caseworker’s file. And it can be the opposite of what your child actually wants. In 29 states, the GAL has to tell the court what the child wants, along with their own recommendation. In 16 states, the court may appoint separate counsel to speak for the child’s wishes when they conflict. Everywhere else, your child’s own voice can get lost in between.

Now let’s talk about money. Who pays the guardian ad litem? Often, you do. According to the Child Welfare Information Gateway, in CPS cases the court pays attorney or GAL fees in 33 states. But 23 states let the court order parents to reimburse those fees, to the extent they can pay. In Tennessee, the person found responsible for the abuse or neglect pays. In Virginia, the court must order a parent or petitioning party to reimburse the state for the GAL’s fee. It can reduce or waive the fee if you can’t pay. In Washington custody cases, the court may order one or both parents to pay the GAL, based on ability to pay. So think about what that means. The person deciding what to say about your parenting, the person whose report the judge will nearly always follow, may be billing you for the privilege.

But that bill can also work for you. Washington requires non-volunteer GALs to give the parties an itemized monthly accounting. Billing records show how much time the GAL actually spent with your child. A recommendation built on two short visits looks very different once you can prove it was two short visits. And in Florida, a GAL appointment order opens your confidential medical, mental health, school and financial records. One appointment, and a stranger to your family can read your private history.

So what happens when a GAL gets it badly wrong? Can you sue? It’s very hard. In 1984, in Kurzawa versus Mueller, the Sixth Circuit, which covers Michigan, Ohio, Kentucky and Tennessee, held that a GAL was entitled to absolute immunity. The court reasoned that GALs need protection from suits by, in its words, dissatisfied parents.

Dissatisfied parents. That’s how the court described mothers and fathers who believe a court-appointed adult got their family wrong. Florida writes it straight into law. The statute presumes GAL program participants act in good faith, and makes them immune from civil or criminal liability. Immunity rules do vary by circuit and by state, and courts disagree about acts outside the GAL’s court role. But for most parents, a lawsuit is not a realistic way out. So you’d think there’s an oversight office somewhere. Look at what the state offices say themselves. Arizona’s legislative ombudsman has no jurisdiction over the judge, the GAL or the CASA. Washington’s family ombuds can’t investigate court decisions, attorneys or CASA GALs. West Virginia’s foster care ombudsman can’t act against GALs, prosecutors or judges. Georgia’s Office of the Child Advocate has no authority over superior court GALs, and refers you to the bar or the judge. Add it up. A GAL can shape where your child lives, see your medical records, and bill you for the work. And still be shielded from the very parents it affects.

So do these programs at least get children home? Here’s what one federal audit found. In 2006, the U.S. Department of Justice Inspector General found that children with a CASA volunteer were reunified with a parent 40.8 percent of the time, compared with 54 percent nationally. And they stayed in foster care longer. 15.8 months, versus 13.8. Now, to be accurate, the Inspector General warned that CASA volunteers are often assigned the most serious cases. So the audit doesn’t prove CASA caused those results. But it gives parents no reason to assume a CASA will help them bring their child home. A program with this much influence, and the federal audit on it shows its children going home less often and staying in care longer.

Recommendations nearly always accepted. Immunity in some courts. No ombudsman review in several states. Add that up, and you get unchecked power over families.

If a GAL is in your case right now, here’s how to push back. This isn’t legal advice. FAN is not a law firm. Work through these with your lawyer, and start early. Problems raised before trial have a better chance than problems raised after the order. One. Measure the GAL against the job. Statutes in 42 states list specific GAL duties, like meeting your child face to face regularly, doing an independent investigation instead of repeating the caseworker, attending hearings, and filing written reports. Ask the GAL in writing how many times they’ve seen your child and who they’ve talked to. Two. Request three papers early. The appointment order, which shows what the GAL was told to do. The fee order, which shows who pays and whether your ability to pay was considered. And the itemized bill, which shows how much time the GAL actually spent with your child. If you can’t afford the fees, tell the court in writing and ask about a reduction or waiver. Don’t simply stop paying a court-ordered fee. Three. Keep your own dated log of every GAL contact with your child. Date, place, how long. Give the GAL your documents in writing, and keep proof you did. Four. Respond to the report in writing. In Washington custody cases, for example, the report is due 60 days before trial, and the court must consider your written response. Ask your lawyer about calling the GAL as a witness, and whether the recommendation came from the GAL’s own investigation or just the caseworker’s report. Five. Use every complaint route that exists. The GAL program. Minnesota’s State GAL Board takes complaints from parties within 30 calendar days, and Washington requires a program review within 5 judicial days. The state bar, if the GAL is a lawyer. And the judge, who can remove a GAL. Washington lets a party who is still dissatisfied after a program review ask the court to remove them. And don’t coach your child on what to say, and don’t argue with the GAL in front of your child. Keep the record clean, and keep it yours. If you need help turning what happened into a clear, documented record, go to fathers advocacy network dot com slash case help.

Our full guide to the guardian ad litem, with every source we used, is on our website, at fathers advocacy network dot com. If this made you angry, share it with a parent who has a GAL in their case and thinks that person is on their side. And follow the show, so you don’t miss the next one. I’m Adam Neuerburg. This is the Father’s Advocacy Network. Let the silenced speak.

Sources
  1. fathersadvocacynetwork.com/guardian-ad-litem/
  2. childwelfare.gov/resources/representation-children-child-abuse-and-neglect-proceedings/
  3. oig.justice.gov/sites/default/files/archive/reports/OJP/a0704/final.pdf
  4. nationalcasagal.org/our-impact/our-reach/
  5. law.cornell.edu/uscode/text/42/5106a
  6. app.leg.wa.gov/RCW/default.aspx?cite=26.12.175
  7. nationalcasagal.org/our-impact/research-and-effectiveness/
  8. nccourts.gov/programs/guardian-ad-litem/volunteer-as-a-gal
  9. nationalcasagal.org/
  10. law.lis.virginia.gov/vacode/title16.1/chapter11/section16.1-267/
  11. guardianadlitem.org/
  12. law.justia.com/cases/federal/appellate-courts/F2/732/1456/130215/
  13. leg.state.fl.us/statutes/index.cfm?App_mode=Display_Statute&URL=0000-0099/0039/Sections/0039.822.html
  14. mn.gov/guardian-ad-litem/contact-us/submit-complaint.jsp
  15. oca.georgia.gov/node/426
  16. oco.virginia.gov/complaints/
  17. mn.gov/guardian-ad-litem/program-information/complaint-procedure.jsp
  18. azoca.gov/child-safety-dcs
  19. ofco.wa.gov/node/12
  20. oig.wv.gov/fco
  21. mn.gov/guardian-ad-litem/
Keep listening

See all episodes →

Scroll to Top