Charleston, West Virginia — The Supreme Court of Appeals of West Virginia has thrown out a family’s lawsuit against the state Department of Human Services and two of its Child Protective Services workers, ruling that the workers have qualified immunity even though, according to the court’s own summary of the record, both saw a 12-year-old boy, whose younger sister had once accused him of sexual assault, walking with the family’s 5-year-old daughter shortly before he allegedly assaulted her at a youth baseball game they were at to supervise. The opinion, filed Nov. 12, 2026, ordered a Harrison County judge to dismiss the agency and the workers from the case before any jury hears it.
The decision, written by Justice Wooton, reverses a June 7, 2024, order by the Circuit Court of Harrison County that would have let a jury decide whether CPS workers Michelle Bast and Aimee Gallo were grossly negligent. The court released the opinion in case No. 24-405. FAN found no news coverage of the ruling.
What happened at the ballpark
According to the opinion, Bast and Gallo went to a youth baseball game on April 24, 2021, to supervise a visit between a 10-year-old girl in DHS’s legal custody and the couple raising her. A circuit court had earlier removed the girl and her 12-year-old brother from that home after she accused him of sexually assaulting her. She later recanted. About two months before the game, the boy was released from the custody of juvenile services with no restrictions and returned to the same couple. The girl was still in DHS custody, and the visit was part of the agency’s plan to reunify the family.
Another family was at the game to watch their son play. When it began to rain, their 5-year-old daughter went to the family car, then left it alone. The lawsuit alleges the 12-year-old intercepted her, lured her behind a concession stand and physically and sexually assaulted her. The opinion states that both CPS workers saw the boy and the girl walking together before the alleged assault and did not intervene. In depositions, the workers said they did not realize the girl was in any danger.
The girl’s parents sued DHS, the two workers and the couple raising the boy. Their complaint alleged the workers knew of the boy’s history of “violent and sexually predatory behavior” against other children, were present specifically because of the girl’s earlier allegation against him, and did nothing. The couple remains a defendant in the circuit court case; they were not part of this appeal.
How the court shut the case down
West Virginia law says no CPS caseworker can be held personally liable for professional decisions, but carves out losses caused by “gross negligence, willful and wanton misconduct, or intentional misconduct.” The circuit court relied on that exception and found the family had offered enough evidence for a jury to weigh gross negligence.
The cases they buried, read out loud.
New138 Out of 140: The Federal Audit That Caught Arkansas Breaking Its Own Child Abuse Rules
Federal auditors checked 140 Arkansas child abuse investigations and found 138 broke the state's own rules. Families were routinely never told how their cases ended, the state's case system has no place to even…

The Supreme Court said the circuit judge asked the wrong question. It held that the gross negligence exception only limits the statute’s protection from personal liability and does not remove the separate, judge-made doctrine of qualified immunity, which shields officials from being sued at all for discretionary decisions. Supervising a family visit, the court said, is a discretionary function.
Read nextWest Virginia Pays $4.4M to Adopted Kids Kept in a Shed After Neighbors Called CPS
To get past qualified immunity, the family had to show the workers violated a clearly established right or law, or acted in a “fraudulent, malicious, or oppressive” way. The court rejected each source the family cited. A state law directing DHS to protect the welfare of the general public was too general. A law requiring CPS to respond immediately to imminent danger did not apply, the court said, because the workers did not perceive any danger. And the CPS Policy Manual, the court repeated from its 2024 decision in West Virginia Department of Human Services v. David B., cannot be a source of clearly established law at all.
The conjecture advanced by the plaintiffs does not defeat qualified immunity.
Justice Wooton, Supreme Court of Appeals of West Virginia, opinion in No. 24-405
The court also pointed out that a circuit judge, not DHS, had returned the boy to the home, that the workers testified they did not know he would be at the game, and that the girl had recanted. It quoted its own earlier rulings that qualified immunity protects the state from claims resting on general notions of what government should have done.
Where the system failed
The ruling does not find that the workers acted properly. It finds that, under West Virginia’s immunity rules, a jury will never be asked. That is the pattern in state after state: the rules agencies write for their own caseworkers carry no weight when a family goes to court, and the bar to reach a jury is set so high that most claims end on paper. In West Virginia, the CPS manual is now twice confirmed by the state’s highest court as unenforceable against the people who are supposed to follow it.
The same agency was the subject of a federal audit that found West Virginia CPS broke federal rules in 91% of sampled abuse reports earlier this month, and a federal appeals court recently revived the class action over the state’s foster care system. Courts elsewhere have drawn the immunity line differently: an appeals court refused to give immunity to a Missouri judge who jailed two children after a custody hearing, a case FAN reported in October.
For families, the lesson is that internal policy violations alone rarely win in court. What matters is a documented record, specific to the worker and the child, made at the time. FAN’s guide on how to file a CPS complaint explains how parents can build that record through formal complaint channels.
What’s next
The Supreme Court remanded the case to the Circuit Court of Harrison County with directions to grant summary judgment to DHS, Bast and Gallo and dismiss them. The family’s claims against the couple raising the boy remain pending in circuit court. Because the opinion resolved the appeal on qualified immunity, the court said it did not need to decide the agency’s separate statutory immunity arguments.
More from West Virginia Department of Human Services
- Appeals Court Revives West Virginia Foster Care Class Action; State Asks Supreme Court to Act
- Studies Tie Removal to the Behavior Problems West Virginia Pays $156,000 a Year to Treat
- West Virginia Still Sends 390 Foster Kids Out of State at $60M a Year, Lawmakers Told
- West Virginia Pays $4.4M to Adopted Kids Kept in a Shed After Neighbors Called CPS
More from West Virginia
- Federal Audit: West Virginia CPS Broke Federal Rules in 91% of Sampled Abuse Reports
- Judge David Camilletti: Due Process Failures in a West Virginia Child Custody Case
- A West Virginia Father Warned the Court His Children Were Being Abused.
- A System That Failed Its Duty: The Complete Documentary Record of the Ronnie Earle Custody Case in Jefferson County, West Virginia
Key facts
- Court: Supreme Court of Appeals of West Virginia, No. 24-405, opinion filed Nov. 12, 2026, by Justice Wooton.
- Ruling: Reversed a June 7, 2024, Harrison County Circuit Court order and directed dismissal of DHS and CPS workers Michelle Bast and Aimee Gallo.
- Incident: April 24, 2021, at a youth baseball game where the two workers were supervising a family visit.
- The opinion says both workers saw a 12-year-old boy, earlier accused by his sister of sexual assault, walking with a 5-year-old girl before the alleged assault.
- The court held a statutory gross negligence exception does not override common-law qualified immunity for CPS workers.
- The court repeated that West Virginia’s CPS Policy Manual cannot establish “clearly established law” to defeat immunity.
- Claims against the couple raising the boy remain pending.
Sources
- CourtListener — West Virginia Department of Human Services, Michelle Bast and Aimee Gallo v. A.Z. and K.Z., Supreme Court of Appeals of West Virginia, No. 24-405 (2026-11-12)
- Supreme Court of Appeals of West Virginia — Signed opinion, No. 24-405 (2026-11-12)
Don’t miss the next one.
Every Monday: the week’s CPS and foster care investigations, court rulings and what families can do. Plus alerts when we report on a case you follow.
Free. Unsubscribe anytime. See our Privacy Policy.
Related Coverage
West VirginiaAppeals Court Revives West Virginia Foster Care Class Action; State Asks Supreme Court to ActNov 14, 2026
West VirginiaStudies Tie Removal to the Behavior Problems West Virginia Pays $156,000 a Year to TreatOct 25, 2026
West VirginiaWest Virginia Still Sends 390 Foster Kids Out of State at $60M a Year, Lawmakers ToldOct 25, 2026
West VirginiaFederal Audit: West Virginia CPS Broke Federal Rules in 91% of Sampled Abuse ReportsNov 12, 2026Don't just read it. Act on it.
Lawmakers fund and oversee this system. Tell West Virginia lawmakers what happened here.
Get an email when this case has a new development: charges, court dates, verdicts, settlements. Only about this case; unsubscribe anytime.
Lived through something like this? Your case could be the next one we document.
Up nextAppeals Court Revives West Virginia Foster Care Class Action; State Asks Supreme Court to ActThe Fourth Circuit revived a class action over West Virginia's foster care system, and the state has now asked the U.S. Supreme Court to review the ruling.
Nov 14, 2026
‘Ten Years Too Long’: How an 8-Year-Old’s ‘No’ and Relatives Nobody Called Kept JoJo Murdock in Foster CareNov 19, 2026
DIED IN CARETexas Review Says Missed Foster Care Visits Likely Contributed to Two Infant DeathsNov 19, 2026
Filed Under ‘Neglect’: How CPS Cases Over Gender Disputes Vanish From the RecordNov 19, 2026


















