Commentary: Too Young to Vote, Old Enough to Pick a Parent. Why Does the System Trust What Children Want?

A child’s words sent fathers to prison, then were taken back. Courts and CPS still treat what children say and want as near-final. Science, and the children themselves, say otherwise.
Exterior of the Queens Family Court building on Jamaica Avenue in New York City
Photo: Jim.henderson / Wikimedia Commons, CC0

This is a FAN commentary. It reflects the views of Father’s Advocacy Network. The facts in it are sourced and linked below.

Chaneya Kelly was two months shy of her ninth birthday when she told police her father had raped her. A jury believed her. Daryl Kelly, a Navy veteran with no prior felony record, was sentenced to 20 to 40 years in prison and barred from contact with his children.

About six months after his conviction, Chaneya told her grandmother it was a lie. She says her mother, then addicted to drugs, threatened to beat her unless she said her father had molested her. Her mother later confirmed the threat in a sworn affidavit and in an interview with NBC News. By the time Chaneya was 24, she was fighting to free him. “It’s never too late to try and right your wrong,” she told NBC. As of NBC’s reporting, prosecutors still stood by the conviction. Read the full story of the Daryl Kelly case.

In Washington state, Cassandra Kennedy was 11 when she said her father raped her. Thomas Kennedy was convicted and sentenced to more than 15 years. At 23, wracked by guilt, she told police she made it up because he had disappointed her and she wanted him to love her. He was freed in 2012 after nearly a decade behind bars, and every charge was dismissed. Read the full story of the Kennedy case.

Two children. Two fathers. Years of freedom, gone, because adults with power over a family took a child’s words and treated them as the final truth.

Those were criminal cases. But the same faith in what a child says, and what a child wants, runs through family courts and child protective services every day, with far less scrutiny and far fewer safeguards. It is time to ask the question the system refuses to answer: since when does a child know best?

We don’t let children decide anything else

A child who wants ice cream for every meal does not get ice cream for every meal. A child who wants to skip school does not get to skip school. A child who says he wants to do something that would permanently hurt his own body is stopped, not supported. That is what parenting is: an adult with love, experience and responsibility deciding what a child is not yet able to decide.

The law agrees, almost everywhere except in the cases that matter most. A 14-year-old cannot vote, cannot sign a binding contract, cannot buy cigarettes and cannot drive alone in most states. But in Georgia, a 14-year-old has the legal right to select which parent to live with, and that choice is presumed correct unless a judge finds it is not in the child’s best interest. Colorado and Utah tell judges to give a child’s wishes added weight at 14, and many other states list a child’s wishes as a factor.

At FAN, we believe raising a child is a duty God has given to parents, not to the government. The U.S. Supreme Court, for its own reasons, has said something similar. It has called the right of parents to the care, custody and control of their children “perhaps the oldest of the fundamental liberty interests” the Court has recognized, and it has held that fit parents are presumed to act in their children’s best interests. That presumption belongs to parents. Somewhere along the way, family courts and child welfare agencies started handing it to children instead.

What the science says about a child’s judgment

According to the National Institute of Mental Health, the brain does not finish developing and maturing until the mid-to-late 20s. The prefrontal cortex, the part responsible for planning, prioritizing and making good decisions, is one of the last parts to mature. In the meantime, the NIMH says, teens focus heavily on peer relationships and may take risks because the social payoff seems bigger than the consequences.

Boys and girls do not develop on the same clock. Researchers at the National Institutes of Health found that gray matter in the brain keeps increasing until about age 11 in girls and about 13 in boys, and girls go through puberty, which reshapes the developing brain, roughly one to two years ahead of boys. On average, that may leave a 14-year-old boy asked to choose a parent even further from mature judgment than a girl the same age. But no child of either sex has a finished brain at 14, or 16, or 18.

The Supreme Court has already accepted this. In Roper v. Simmons in 2005, it barred the death penalty for crimes committed before 18, finding that young people’s lack of maturity often results in “impetuous and ill-considered actions and decisions,” that they are more vulnerable to outside pressure, and that their character is not yet fully formed. The same legal system that says a 17-year-old is too immature to be held fully responsible for a murder lets a 14-year-old in Georgia decide which parent he will live with.

How a child’s voice becomes the deciding vote

On paper, judges say a child’s preference is only one factor. In practice, the system is built to amplify it.

Guardians ad litem are supposed to represent a child’s best interests, not simply repeat what the child wants. But many states require them to tell the court the child’s wishes even when they disagree. Missouri’s court rules, for example, require it. And an influential movement in the legal profession argues that every child, regardless of age, should have a lawyer who advocates for what the child says they want. A 2006 national conference of children’s law experts concluded exactly that.

In child protective services, the weight is even heavier. Researchers who study abuse cases note that other evidence is often unavailable, so children’s reports are weighed heavily in decisions to intervene. A child’s statement to a teacher, a counselor or a caseworker can be the single piece of evidence that opens an investigation, removes a child from home and puts a parent on a registry. FAN has documented cases where that is exactly what happened, including cases where a teenager’s report led to removal and the abuse allegations against the parents were later dropped.

None of that would matter as much if children’s words and wishes could not be shaped by the adults around them. They can.

The FAN Podcast · New episodes every Tuesday & Friday

The cases they buried, read out loud.

New
Episode 20 · Nov 17 · 11 min

138 Out of 140: The Federal Audit That Caught Arkansas Breaking Its Own Child Abuse Rules

Federal auditors checked 140 Arkansas child abuse investigations and found 138 broke the state's own rules. Families were routinely never told how their cases ended, the state's case system has no place to even…

Episode 20 · Nov 17, 2026 · 10:58
0:0010:58

Read nextFiled Under ‘Neglect’: How CPS Cases Over Gender Disputes Vanish From the Record

Children can be turned, and they know it later

Psychologist Amy J.L. Baker interviewed about 40 adults who believed that, as children, they had been turned against one parent by the other. Many said that even while they were insisting loudly that they hated or feared the pushed-out parent, they didn’t fully believe it. Some said they secretly hoped someone would see through what was happening and step in. When they finally understood they had been manipulated, many felt pain, anger, guilt and resentment.

Read that again. The child standing in front of the judge saying, “I never want to see my dad again,” may be the same child praying the judge won’t listen.

Chaneya Kelly’s words came from her mother’s threats. In London, two children accused their father of running a satanic abuse ring in 2014. They later recanted and told police their mother and her partner had forced them to make the allegations, in a process a judge would later describe as “torture.” Children are not small adults with less information. They are children, and they often say what the most powerful adult in their life needs them to say.

‘Ten years too long’

JoJo Murdock was 8 when California removed her from her mother for neglect. When caseworkers raised adoption, they told her it meant getting a “new family.” She refused. She already had a family, broken as it was, and she wanted to keep it. In 2011, at 26, she told the U.S. Senate Finance Committee what came next: no one went back to revisit her answer, no one told her aunt and uncle that she and her sisters were in care, and she spent ten years in the system. She called it “ten years too long.” Read JoJo Murdock’s full story.

An 8-year-old’s “no,” given without understanding, shaped a decade of her life. The adults wrote it down and moved on.

Lamani Moore entered New York foster care at 4 and moved from home to home. Writing in The Imprint, Moore said there were times of wishing to be home, because even though home wasn’t the best, Moore’s voice was actually heard there.

They go home anyway

Here is what the system almost never says out loud: many children it takes from their parents return to those relationships once they are adults.

The Midwest Study, one of the largest long-term studies of young people aging out of foster care, followed more than 700 former foster youth from Iowa, Wisconsin and Illinois. At age 21, nearly three in four had contact with their biological mothers at least once a year, more than a quarter had daily contact with her, and more than half said they felt close to her. A 2025 study in the journal Families in Society describes the same pattern: as young people age out of care, many seek out their birth parents and extended families.

Years of state custody, caseworkers, placements and court orders, and when it is over, the children walk back toward the families they were taken from. If the system’s judgment about those families was always right, why do so many of its own children seek those families out the moment they are allowed to?

The other side

Children who are truly being abused need to be heard and believed, and nothing in this commentary changes that. Research cuts both ways. In a study of 257 child sexual abuse cases that reached dependency court, Lindsay Malloy, Thomas Lyon and Jodi Quas found that about 23% of children recanted, and that recantation was more likely when the child was younger, the abuser was a parent and the other parent did not support the child. They found no support for the idea that those recantations were false allegations. Children can be pressured into lying about abuse, and they can be pressured into taking back the truth.

That is the point. A child’s words can be bent in either direction by the adults around them. That is exactly why a child’s words and wishes should never carry the weight of a final decision. Hearing a child is not the same as handing a child the gavel.

Advocates for children’s legal representation argue that young people deserve a voice in decisions about their own lives, and that ignoring them causes harm too. We agree that children should be heard. We do not agree that they should decide.

What has to change

No child should be removed from a home, and no parent should lose custody, on the strength of a child’s statement or preference alone. Outside a true emergency, the state should have independent evidence that holds up on its own before it acts.

Every interview of a child in an abuse investigation should be recorded, from the first conversation. Even researchers who study recantation recommend documenting early disclosures on audio or video. A recording protects true victims and falsely accused parents alike, and it shows a judge whether a child’s words were the child’s own.

Laws like Georgia’s, which presume a 14-year-old’s choice of parent is correct, should be repealed. A child’s preference should be one factor, weighed by adults, never a presumption.

Guardians ad litem should be required to investigate who might be influencing a child’s statements before they report them as the child’s wishes, and to say so in writing. Our guide explains what GALs do and what to do when they get it wrong, and our research shows how CPS turns parents against each other, which is often how a child’s loyalties get bent in the first place.

And states should follow up with young adults who were removed as children and ask them one question: looking back, was it right? No state that FAN knows of asks. Until someone does, the system will keep counting a child’s words as truth and never count the adults who later wish they could take them back.

If you were that child

If you were a child whose words or wishes were used to remove you from a parent, and you now see it differently, we want to hear from you. If you are a parent who lost your child because of what your child said or wanted, we want to hear from you too. Send us a confidential tip. Parents in the middle of a case can start with our guides on your rights in a CPS investigation, family and dependency court and fathers’ rights.

Key facts

  • Chaneya Kelly says her mother forced her, at almost 9, to falsely accuse her father, Daryl Kelly, who was sentenced to 20 to 40 years. Prosecutors stood by the conviction as of NBC News’ reporting.
  • Cassandra Kennedy recanted at 23 the rape accusation she made at 11. Her father, Thomas Kennedy, was freed in 2012 after nearly a decade in prison.
  • The National Institute of Mental Health says the brain finishes maturing in the mid-to-late 20s; girls reach puberty, which reshapes the brain, about one to two years ahead of boys.
  • In Roper v. Simmons (2005), the Supreme Court found juveniles more immature and more vulnerable to outside pressure than adults.
  • Georgia law gives a 14-year-old the right to select which parent to live with, presumed correct unless a judge finds otherwise.
  • At 21, about 74% of former foster youth in the Midwest Study had at least yearly contact with their biological mothers.
  • About 23% of children in one study of sexual abuse cases in dependency court recanted; the researchers found no evidence those recantations were false allegations.

Sources

The FAN Briefing

Don’t miss the next one.

Every Monday: the week’s CPS and foster care investigations, court rulings and what families can do. Plus alerts when we report on a case you follow.

Free. Unsubscribe anytime. See our Privacy Policy.

Related Coverage

More FAN investigations →
What you can do

Don't just read it. Act on it.

Lawmakers fund and oversee this system. Tell your members of Congress what happened here.

Open in my email

Get an email when this case has a new development: charges, court dates, verdicts, settlements. Only about this case; unsubscribe anytime.

Lived through something like this? Your case could be the next one we document.

Read next

This story exists because families spoke up.

Father’s Advocacy Network is a nonprofit newsroom. We don’t take money from the agencies we cover. Help us keep exposing what happens behind closed doors.

About Father’s Advocacy Network. We investigate failures inside CPS, foster care, adoption and family court — and stand with parents fighting to bring their children home. Have a correction or a tip? Contact our newsroom.

Most Read

Is this happening to your family?

Tell us your story — confidentially. Every case we cover starts with a parent speaking up.

Join the conversation

Have something to add? Create a free account or log in to comment. Accounts keep the discussion real and free of bots.

Create free accountLog in

Scroll to Top