From the archive: This story covers a lawsuit filed in February 2026 over a death in November 2025. FAN is adding past cases to its public record; the latest available information is under “Where it stands.”
Long Beach, California — The mother of a 14-month-old girl who prosecutors say was tortured to death in Long Beach has sued the Los Angeles County Department of Children and Family Services, alleging the agency placed her daughter with a father who had already served a prison sentence for child abuse and had pleaded no contest in a second child abuse case. The father and the girl’s stepmother are charged with murder.
Alexis Servin filed the lawsuit on Feb. 19, 2026, the Los Angeles Times reported. Her attorneys are seeking $50 million, according to ABC7 Los Angeles. Her daughter, Tilly Servin, died on Nov. 10, 2025.
What happened to Tilly
Tilly was admitted to Miller Children’s Hospital in Long Beach on Nov. 7, 2025, and placed on life support, according to the Los Angeles County District Attorney’s Office as reported by WFSB. She died three days later. Her father, Alfredo Muñoz Jr., 41, and stepmother, Kelly Muñoz, 34, were arrested on Nov. 24. Each is charged with murder, torture and assault on a child causing death, and each faces up to 32 years to life in prison if convicted. Bail was set at $3 million.
The Los Angeles County medical examiner found injuries that could not be explained by a single accidental fall, including blunt head trauma and a severe spinal cord injury, and concluded she suffered repeated inflicted trauma, the Times reported. Deputy District Attorney Brian Rosenberg said she died of a skull fracture, had several broken bones, including a tibia broken twice, and had been starved until she was emaciated, according to the Times. The father initially told authorities he tripped over a baby gate while holding her. Both defendants have pleaded not guilty, the Times reported.
The record DCFS had
Servin lost custody when Tilly was about 5 months old. She told the Times that DCFS removed her daughter after an alleged positive fentanyl test, which she denies. Tilly lived briefly with her grandfather before the agency placed her with her father.
The father’s history was in public court records. In November 2021, the Times reported, he and his wife were charged with felony abuse of two children after police found methamphetamine and pill bottles within reach of the children at their Long Beach home, along with two firearms. Neither child was physically injured, and both adults pleaded no contest. Muñoz had previously been sentenced to four years in prison for child abuse, had arrests for burglary, assault, vehicle theft, weapons and drug offenses, and was last released from state prison in 2023, according to court and corrections records cited by the Times.
Read nextFiled Under ‘Neglect’: How CPS Cases Over Gender Disputes Vanish From the Record
The lawsuit says DCFS had opened a case connected to the couple’s 2021 charges. According to the Times, a DCFS dependency investigator emailed Servin on March 5 warning that the father’s substance abuse history made him “incapable of providing regular care of the child.”
What the lawsuit claims
The suit alleges DCFS knew of the couple’s violent history and should have known they posed an extreme and foreseeable danger to Tilly, the Times reported. ABC7 reported that the family’s attorneys accuse the agency of acting recklessly by placing the toddler with a father who had a criminal history and known drug problems. Servin is represented by Brian Claypool, who also represented relatives in the Anthony Avalos and Noah Cuatro cases, which the county settled for $32 million and $20 million.
This is as bad as it gets.
Brian Claypool, attorney for Alexis Servin, to the Los Angeles Times
DCFS said it was deeply saddened by the death and that state law bars it from discussing the case further.
Where the system failed
If the mother’s account and the lawsuit’s are accurate, DCFS removed a baby from her mother over a drug test the mother disputes, then handed her to a man whose own drug and child abuse record was documented in criminal court and in the agency’s own files, after one of its investigators had warned in writing that he could not care for her. That is not a resource problem. It is a decision, and the people who made it have not had to explain it in public. California’s confidentiality law lets the agency say nothing while the case proceeds.
Los Angeles County’s placement decisions have already been tested in court this year: in February a federal jury ordered Los Angeles County to pay $9 million to a mother whose infant died of dehydration in a foster home where other children had died. A state review FAN reported this month found that California placed children before completing required safety checks.
Parents who lose custody over a contested test often have little say in where their child goes next. FAN’s guide to parents’ rights in CPS cases explains what parents can ask the court to review, including relative and parent placements.
Where it stands
The criminal case against Alfredo and Kelly Muñoz and Servin’s civil suit against the county were both pending as of the most recent coverage FAN found. FAN found no published report of a trial date, plea or ruling in either case since the lawsuit was filed. The articles do not identify the court where the civil suit was filed.
Key facts
- Tilly Servin, 14 months old, died Nov. 10, 2025, three days after she was hospitalized in Long Beach.
- Her father, Alfredo Muñoz Jr., 41, and stepmother, Kelly Muñoz, 34, are charged with murder, torture and assault on a child causing death; both pleaded not guilty.
- Muñoz had previously served a four-year prison sentence for child abuse and pleaded no contest in a 2021 felony child abuse case, according to records cited by the Los Angeles Times.
- A DCFS dependency investigator wrote on March 5 that the father’s substance abuse history made him “incapable of providing regular care of the child,” the Times reported.
- Mother Alexis Servin sued DCFS on Feb. 19, 2026; her attorneys seek $50 million, ABC7 reported.
- Servin says DCFS removed Tilly after an alleged positive fentanyl test, which she denies.
- DCFS cited state confidentiality law and declined to comment further.
Sources
- Los Angeles Times (via AOL) — Toddler died after L.A. County placed her with dad previously jailed for abuse, lawsuit says (2026-02-25)
- ABC7 Los Angeles — LA County DCFS facing $50 million lawsuit over death of toddler (2026-02-26)
- WFSB (Gray News) — Father, stepmother accused of torturing, killing 14-month-old girl (2025-12-04)
Don't just read it. Act on it.
Lawmakers fund and oversee this system. Tell California lawmakers what happened here.
Get an email when this case has a new development: charges, court dates, verdicts, settlements. Only about this case; unsubscribe anytime.
Lived through something like this? Your case could be the next one we document.
Don’t miss the next one.
Every Monday: the week’s CPS and foster care investigations, court rulings and what families can do. Plus alerts when we report on a case you follow.
Free. Unsubscribe anytime. See our Privacy Policy.


















