Washington, D.C. — JoJo Murdock was 8 years old when California removed her from her mother. She would not leave foster care for ten years. In March 2011, at 26, she sat before the U.S. Senate Finance Committee and explained why: an answer she gave as a little girl that no one ever revisited, and relatives no one ever called.
Her story is one of the cases FAN cited in our commentary, “Too Young to Vote, Old Enough to Pick a Parent,” on how much weight the system gives to what children say and want. This is the full account, drawn from her Senate testimony.
A broken family, but hers
Murdock’s mother was a single mother of three, poor and mentally ill, and often unable to keep stable housing or child care. Murdock was removed for neglect after being left alone for long stretches. Her two sisters had been placed with their fathers. Her mother asked that she be placed for adoption.
When caseworkers explained adoption to her, they told her it meant getting a new family. She refused. She already had a family, broken as it was, and she wanted to hold on to it.
Looking back, she told senators, she wished someone had explained adoption as adding people to her family, not replacing them. And she wished someone had come back and asked her again after that first refusal. No one did. An 8-year-old’s “no,” given without understanding what it meant, became the plan.
The aunt and uncle nobody called
Murdock had an aunt and uncle who were never told that she and her sisters were in trouble. She did not learn about them until years later, after a long stretch in foster care. She told the committee she believes they would have helped.
She spent a decade in the system. She called it “ten years too long.”
The cases they buried, read out loud.
New138 Out of 140: The Federal Audit That Caught Arkansas Breaking Its Own Child Abuse Rules
Federal auditors checked 140 Arkansas child abuse investigations and found 138 broke the state's own rules. Families were routinely never told how their cases ended, the state's case system has no place to even…

Read nextHow a 1997 Law Put a Bounty on Adoption and a Clock on Every Foster Family
After 18
Murdock aged out at 18. She struggled, and she told the committee she would have been homeless without her sister’s housing. Other things helped her survive: sports and activities, mentors from church camp, frequent contact with her sister Cynthia, and her foster mother, Sue Crowely, who stayed in her life. At 25, she was legally adopted. When she testified, Murdock was married, finishing a bachelor’s degree at UC Santa Barbara and working to connect foster youth with supportive adults.
What the law requires now
Part of what happened to Murdock would now violate a federal requirement, at least on paper. The Fostering Connections to Success and Increasing Adoptions Act, signed on Oct. 7, 2008, requires child welfare agencies to use due diligence to identify and notify all adult grandparents and other adult relatives within 30 days after a child is removed from home, with exceptions for family or domestic violence. Relatives must be told about their options to become a placement for the child.
But the law has limits. It does not require any further outreach to relatives after those first 30 days, according to the Grandfamilies State Law and Policy Resource Center. A relative who is missed, or who cannot step in at first, may never hear from the agency again.
The numbers show how uneven relative placement still is. In fiscal year 2024, about 39% of children in U.S. foster care lived with relatives or kin, according to the U.S. Department of Health and Human Services. That ranged from 11% to 57% depending on the state. Among children living with kin, 44% were in unlicensed homes, which generally means their relatives do not receive the foster care maintenance payments that licensed foster parents do.
In Los Angeles County, DCFS told reporters this month that about 45% of children entering foster care there live with relatives or family friends. That statement came in response to the death of 4-month-old Ariel Rivera Salazar, who was placed in a foster home the day after she was removed.
Where the system failed
JoJo Murdock’s case shows the system failing in two directions at once. By her account, it treated a child’s answer as final when she was too young to understand the question. And it never told the family who could have changed the answer.
Both failures come from the same habit: treating a case file as a substitute for people. An 8-year-old’s answer was taken, and in her telling, no one came back to it. No one told her aunt and uncle. The girl who said no to adoption at 8 was adopted anyway, at 25, long after it could change her childhood.
Children deserve to be heard. They do not deserve to carry decisions that belong to adults. And no child should spend a decade in care while family members who would have helped never get a phone call. FAN’s position is that relatives should be searched for at the start of every case and again whenever a plan stalls, not just once in the first 30 days. For more on how the system handles placement, see Foster Care System Problems: What the Data Shows. Parents and relatives can start with our guide to your rights in a CPS investigation.
Key facts
- JoJo Murdock was removed from her mother for neglect at 8 and spent ten years in California foster care.
- Told adoption meant a “new family,” she refused it. She says no one revisited that answer.
- Her aunt and uncle were never told she was in care. She learned of them years later.
- She aged out at 18 and was legally adopted at 25.
- The 2008 Fostering Connections Act requires agencies to notify adult relatives within 30 days of a removal, but requires no outreach after that.
- In FY 2024, about 39% of U.S. foster children lived with relatives or kin, ranging from 11% to 57% by state.
Sources
- U.S. Senate Finance Committee — Testimony of JoJo Murdock, “Innovations in Child Welfare Waivers” (2011-03-10)
- Child Welfare Information Gateway — Fostering Connections to Success and Increasing Adoptions Act of 2008 (P.L. 110-351)
- Administration for Children and Families — Program Instruction ACYF-CB-PI-10-11 (2010)
- Grandfamilies State Law and Policy Resource Center — Notification and Engagement of Relatives
- HHS ASPE — States Promote Kinship Care, Though Opportunity Remains
- Grandfamilies State Law and Policy Resource Center — Foster Care Licensing
- ABC7 Los Angeles — Family of 4-month-old who died while in foster care files federal claim against LA County (2026-11-19)
Don’t miss the next one.
Every Monday: the week’s CPS and foster care investigations, court rulings and what families can do. Plus alerts when we report on a case you follow.
Free. Unsubscribe anytime. See our Privacy Policy.
Related Coverage
CaliforniaRescued From Torture, Abused Again.Jul 1, 2026
CaliforniaFiled Under ‘Neglect’: How CPS Cases Over Gender Disputes Vanish From the RecordNov 19, 2026
NationalCommentary: Too Young to Vote, Old Enough to Pick a Parent. Why Does the System Trust What Children Want?Nov 19, 2026
California4-Month-Old Ariel Rivera Salazar Dies 19 Days After LA County Removed HerNov 19, 2026Don't just read it. Act on it.
Lawmakers fund and oversee this system. Tell California lawmakers what happened here.
Get an email when this case has a new development: charges, court dates, verdicts, settlements. Only about this case; unsubscribe anytime.
Lived through something like this? Your case could be the next one we document.
GAL MISCONDUCTUp nextCommentary: Too Young to Vote, Old Enough to Pick a Parent. Why Does the System Trust What Children Want?A child’s words sent fathers to prison, then were taken back. Courts and CPS still treat what children say and want as near-final. Science, and the children themselves,…
Nov 19, 2026
DIED IN CARETexas Review Says Missed Foster Care Visits Likely Contributed to Two Infant DeathsNov 19, 2026
Filed Under ‘Neglect’: How CPS Cases Over Gender Disputes Vanish From the RecordNov 19, 2026
Florida Appeals Court Orders Drug Testing Removed from Mother’s Child Welfare PlanNov 19, 2026

















