Filed Under ‘Neglect’: How CPS Cases Over Gender Disputes Vanish From the Record

Parents in Indiana, Massachusetts and Los Angeles say CPS took their kids over gender. The official labels say neglect or abuse, and FAN found no data system that counts these cases.
The west front of the U.S. Capitol in Washington, D.C.
Photo: Martin Falbisoner / Wikimedia Commons, CC BY-SA 3.0 (cropped)

When the Indiana Department of Child Services took a 16-year-old from Mary and Jeremy Cox in 2021, it filed the case as neglect. When Massachusetts took Joseph and Arlene Kutzko’s 15-year-old, the state cleared them of physical abuse but upheld a finding of neglect, a finding the parents say no one has ever explained to them. When Los Angeles County took Abigail Martinez’s daughter, Yaeli, the allegation, according to Martinez, was that she had slapped her.

In each case, the parents say the real dispute was over their child’s gender identity. In each case, the official label was something else.

FAN reviewed court opinions, U.S. Supreme Court filings, state records reported by news organizations, federal data definitions and state policy documents in five of these cases. They show something that has been missing from the national debate. Whatever caused these removals, the way child welfare systems classify cases means a removal tied to a gender dispute is recorded as neglect, abuse, or a problem with the child, and never as what the parents say it was. FAN could find no state or federal data system that counts these cases, so no one can say how often they happen.

That gap is now at the center of a bill in Congress. The Yaeli Martinez Child Protection Act, introduced as S. 5593 by Sen. Eric Schmitt, R-Mo., on Sept. 29 and as H.R. 10745 by Rep. Mary Miller, R-Ill., on Oct. 5, would bar child welfare agencies that take federal money from removing children, issuing abuse or neglect findings, or putting parents on abuse registries solely because the parents raise a child according to the child’s sex or refuse gender-transition treatment. Bill-tracking records show no action on either bill beyond introduction.

The bill drew new attention this month when Laura Hanford, a senior policy analyst at The Heritage Foundation, discussed it in a Nov. 12 interview with The Epoch Times program “American Thought Leaders.”

Indiana: filed as neglect, kept as the child’s illness

The Indiana case is the only one of these that has produced a published appeals court opinion, and the record shows how a case can change labels while the child stays out of the home.

According to the Indiana Court of Appeals, DCS received two reports in May 2021 that the Coxes were verbally and emotionally abusing their 16-year-old because they did not accept the teen’s transgender identity. DCS filed a petition calling the child a “child in need of services” under two sections of Indiana law: one for a child endangered by a parent’s neglect, the other for harm caused by a parent’s acts or omissions. In June 2021, a judge removed the teen, citing the parents’ “inability, refusal or neglect” to provide care, and cautioned them not to discuss the child’s transgender identity during visits.

The parents’ petition to the U.S. Supreme Court says the investigation began with reports that they were not using a cross-gender name for their child, and that DCS’s removal request cited their refusal to accept LGBTQ parenting resources. At the first hearing, according to the petition, DCS said the teen should be in a home where she is accepted for who she is.

Five months later, DCS agreed to dismiss both neglect and abuse allegations and to unsubstantiate and expunge the reports against the parents. But the child did not go home. DCS had added a third allegation: that the teen was endangering their own health through a worsening eating disorder. The teen admitted to that finding, and the court kept the child out of the home under it, finding the eating disorder was partly fueled by isolation from the parents.

The Court of Appeals upheld the removal in October 2022. It said the case was about the child’s health, not the parents’ beliefs, and that the link between the family’s disagreement and the child’s illness did not turn it into a neglect case. The U.S. Supreme Court declined to hear the parents’ appeal on March 18, 2024. Indiana’s attorney general argued the removal was about the eating disorder, not the gender dispute.

Whatever one makes of the court’s reasoning, the result on paper is clear. The parents were cleared of neglect and abuse. Their child stayed in state custody anyway. And the case was officially resolved as a child’s eating disorder.

Massachusetts: abuse ‘not supported,’ neglect upheld

The Kutzkos’ case is still open, and it is more complicated than either side’s public account.

Court records reviewed by WBUR and The Boston Globe show Joseph Kutzko was charged with misdemeanor assault after his then-15-year-old reported an incident at the family’s Southborough home on Jan. 28, 2025. A police detective wrote that he punched the teen in the shoulder and pulled the teen’s hair. Arlene Kutzko was later charged with witness intimidation in connection with the same incident. The family denies the abuse allegations. Their lawyer, Vernadette Broyles, told The Epoch Times that Joseph Kutzko accepted pretrial probation in December 2025, under which he will avoid trial and have his record expunged.

Gov. Maura Healey has said DCF removed the child after criminal charges were filed, not because of a health or gender-affirming care issue. The local school district has said a disagreement between a parent and student over gender identity would not prompt a call to police or DCF.

But DCF’s own finding did not rest on the abuse allegation. According to a letter the family’s lawyer shared with The Boston Globe, DCF told the Kutzkos in February 2025 that the abuse allegations were not supported. DCF did support a finding of neglect against both parents. The Kutzkos say they have never been told why. Broyles told The Epoch Times that DCF’s continuing custody claim rests on that neglect allegation.

The FAN Podcast · New episodes every Tuesday & Friday

The cases they buried, read out loud.

New
Episode 20 · Nov 17 · 11 min

138 Out of 140: The Federal Audit That Caught Arkansas Breaking Its Own Child Abuse Rules

Federal auditors checked 140 Arkansas child abuse investigations and found 138 broke the state's own rules. Families were routinely never told how their cases ended, the state's case system has no place to even…

Episode 20 · Nov 17, 2026 · 10:58
0:0010:58

Meanwhile, according to The Boston Globe, DCF supported a plan to give the now-17-year-old hormone treatments. A judge paused that plan. The U.S. Department of Education opened an investigation into the school district in September over its parental-rights policies. The teen turns 18 in April.

Los Angeles: an allegation that was later cleared

The case the federal bill is named for never reached an appeals court, and almost everything known about it comes from Yaeli Martinez’s mother. Los Angeles County has not publicly addressed it, and state law generally bars DCFS from discussing child welfare cases.

Abigail Martinez has said her daughter struggled with bullying and depression as a young teen and began questioning her sexuality around 15. According to Martinez’s account to the Daily Mail, as reported by The Daily Wire, a friend and the friend’s parents coached Yaeli to leave home and tell DCFS that Martinez had slapped her. Yaeli was placed in a group home at 16, and Martinez was put on the state’s child abuse registry. A judge allowed Yaeli to receive cross-sex hormones. Martinez was limited to one hour of supervised visits a week.

Martinez says she was later cleared of the abuse allegation and removed from the registry. About two months later, in 2019, Yaeli died by suicide at 19, according to her mother’s account reported by The Center Square.

Read nextFederal Jury Hits LA County DCFS With $9M Verdict in Foster Infant’s Dehydration Death

Montana and Connecticut

In Montana, Todd and Krista Kolstad said they lost custody of their 14-year-old daughter in January 2024 because they opposed her transition. Montana’s records told a different story, according to the Daily Montanan: officials received at least two law enforcement calls in August 2023 about the teen’s mental health, including suicide threats, and focused on the risk of immediate harm. The state also raised concerns about the father’s alcohol use and aggressive behavior, which the couple denied. A judge awarded custody to the teen’s biological mother in Canada. CBN reported that the judge’s order faulted the Kolstads for focusing on the teen’s struggle with gender identity rather than problems in the home. Republican Gov. Greg Gianforte defended the agency.

In Connecticut, Elvira Syed told The Epoch Times that the state Department of Children and Families accused her of being an unsafe parent after her daughter began identifying as transgender, and that the allegations were dismissed after a hearing in December 2023. According to The Epoch Times, her daughter began testosterone in June 2024 and died that October.

Why the data can’t see it

Every state reports child abuse and neglect cases to the federal National Child Abuse and Neglect Data System, known as NCANDS. It sorts cases into a small set of maltreatment types, among them neglect, medical neglect, physical abuse, sexual abuse, and psychological or emotional maltreatment. Federal guidance has long described neglect to include failing to provide necessary medical or mental health treatment, and emotional neglect to include failing to provide psychological care.

None of these categories records whether a case involved a disagreement over a child’s gender identity. Under those categories, a case like the Coxes’ could be reported as alleged neglect and closed as unsubstantiated, while the child’s continued custody rests on the child’s own condition. A case like the Kutzkos’ would show up as supported neglect. If an agency treats a parent’s refusal of gender-related treatment as a failure to meet a child’s medical or emotional needs, the federal data would record only neglect or emotional maltreatment.

There is evidence that some in the field want those refusals treated that way:

  • A 2024 article in Pediatrics, the journal of the American Academy of Pediatrics, argued that withholding gender-affirming care amounts to “state-sanctioned medical neglect and emotional abuse.” The article was written about state laws banning such care, but its framing defines withholding the care as neglect.
  • The Massachusetts Commission on LGBTQ Youth, a state advisory body, recommended in 2023 that Massachusetts “explicitly include the withholding of gender-affirming care” in its child abuse laws, and that DCF explore an LGBTQ youth maltreatment code. FAN found no sign that either recommendation has been adopted.
  • North Carolina’s state child welfare guidance tells workers assessing safety to consider whether parents’ attitudes toward a child’s sexual orientation or gender identity are affecting the youth’s immediate safety.
  • When California Gov. Gavin Newsom vetoed a 2023 bill that would have required custody judges to weigh a parent’s affirmation of a child’s gender identity, he said existing law already requires courts to consider it as part of a child’s health, safety and welfare.

FAN found no state law that explicitly makes refusing a child’s gender transition, by itself, abuse or neglect. But the definitions that do exist are broad enough to hold it, and the data systems built on them cannot tell it apart from any other neglect case.

Whether that is deliberate or simply how the system was built, the effect is the same. Agencies can point to records that never mention gender. Families can say, and sometimes show, that the gender dispute is where their case began. Confidentiality rules keep the public from checking either claim.

What the bill would change

According to Schmitt’s office, the Yaeli Martinez Child Protection Act would:

  • Bar federal child welfare funds from being used to treat raising, referring to or caring for a child according to the child’s sex as abuse or neglect.
  • Prohibit federally funded systems from removing a child, starting dependency proceedings, restricting visits, issuing an abuse or neglect finding, placing a parent on a registry, terminating parental rights or denying a foster or adoptive placement solely because a parent affirms the child’s sex.
  • Restrict federal funds for what the bill calls “sex-rejecting interventions” for children in state care.
  • Let parents, guardians, caregivers and children sue over violations.
  • Amend the Parental Kidnapping Prevention Act so a state cannot disregard another state’s custody order when a child is taken, or runs, there for those interventions.

It would apply across the main federal child welfare funding streams, including CAPTA and Titles IV-B and IV-E of the Social Security Act. Miller’s House version had 12 original cosponsors, all Republicans. Supporters include The Heritage Foundation, Concerned Women for America, CatholicVote, Do No Harm and Moms for Liberty.

Raising your son as a boy or your daughter as a girl is fundamental to parenthood, not child abuse.

Rep. Mary Miller, R-Ill., in a news release announcing the House bill

The bill has a built-in limit, and the cases above show why it matters. It protects parents from action taken solely because of their position on gender. In Indiana, the court said the removal rested on an eating disorder. In Massachusetts, the governor points to an assault charge. In Montana, the state cited suicide threats. Under the bill, those cases would turn on the same question they turn on now: whether the stated reason was the real one. The bill does not require agencies to record or report when a case involves a gender dispute, so the data gap would remain.

Federal policy has already shifted. In July 2026, the U.S. Department of Health and Human Services finalized the rescission of a 2024 rule that required states to ensure LGBTQ-affirming “designated placements” for foster youth who requested them. A federal court had already halted that rule.

The other side

FAN found no public statement yet from LGBTQ advocacy groups on the federal bill, but critics of similar state laws have been direct. When Oklahoma’s Right to Raise Act took effect Nov. 1, opponents said it could deny transgender youth access to care and expose them to conversion therapy. In Ohio, Equality Ohio said a similar bill would block judges and child protective services from responding appropriately to abuse involving LGBTQ+ kids. In Georgia, a Children’s Rights lawyer told The Imprint a comparable bill puts “a target on the backs of children.”

Critics also point out that LGBTQ+ youth are heavily overrepresented in foster care. A 2019 California study cited by The Imprint found about 30% of foster youth identified as LGBTQ+ and about 5% as transgender, compared with about 11% and 1% of other youth. The Trevor Project reports that LGBTQ+ youth with at least one accepting adult are 40% less likely to attempt suicide. In their view, a law like this one could make it harder for agencies to protect young people facing rejection or mistreatment at home.

And in several of the cases above, the agencies point to evidence that has nothing to do with gender: a criminal assault charge, an eating disorder, suicide threats. Those facts are part of the record, and they are why each case has to be judged on its own.

Where the system failed

FAN’s position is that a parent’s refusal to approve a child’s social or medical transition should never, by itself, be a reason to take a child from home. Parents and teenagers disagree, sometimes bitterly, about identity, faith and medical care. A disagreement is not danger. Removal is the most drastic power the state has over a family, and it is supposed to be reserved for children who cannot safely stay home.

The records FAN reviewed show why that line is so hard to enforce. In Indiana, the neglect and abuse allegations were dropped and expunged, and the child stayed in custody under a different label. In Massachusetts, the abuse allegation was not supported, and a neglect finding the parents say no one has explained is, according to their lawyer, the basis for keeping their child in state custody. In Los Angeles, a mother says she was cleared only after it was too late to bring her daughter home. In every case, the official reason could be defended on paper, and the reason the parents describe never appears in any count.

When a system cannot be measured, it cannot be held accountable. If agencies are not removing children over gender disputes, they should have no objection to tracking and reporting every case in which a gender dispute was part of the record. Until someone counts, families will keep telling stories that agencies cannot confirm, and agencies will keep giving reasons that families cannot check.

This is the same wall FAN hits in other cases. When a 4-month-old died in Los Angeles County foster care this fall, DCFS said state law barred it from confirming any involvement with the family. Our research on removals found that about three in four are filed as neglect, the broadest category in child welfare.

If this is happening to your family

If you are being investigated, or your child has been removed, ask in writing for the specific allegation and the specific finding against you. A finding of “neglect” should name what you failed to provide. FAN’s guides cover your rights in a CPS investigation, what happens during an investigation, dependency court and how to file a complaint against CPS. We have also reported on a Maryland couple who say CPS treated their Christian faith as proof they were unfit and on medical disputes in which the state overrode parents’ decisions. If your case involves a dispute over your child’s gender identity, send us a confidential tip. We are collecting these cases because no one else is counting them.

Key facts

  • In Indiana, DCS removed a 16-year-old in 2021 under neglect and abuse allegations tied to a gender identity dispute. Those allegations were later dismissed and expunged, and the child remained in custody under a finding that the teen was endangering their own health. The U.S. Supreme Court declined to hear the parents’ appeal on March 18, 2024.
  • In Massachusetts, DCF found abuse allegations against Joseph and Arlene Kutzko not supported but upheld a neglect finding that the parents say has never been explained. The father was charged with misdemeanor assault and accepted pretrial probation. The governor says the removal followed criminal charges, not gender.
  • In Los Angeles County, Abigail Martinez says her daughter Yaeli was removed at 16 after an abuse allegation she was later cleared of. Yaeli died by suicide in 2019 at 19.
  • The federal NCANDS system has no category for removals tied to gender identity disputes. Such cases are recorded as neglect, abuse or a child’s own condition.
  • The Yaeli Martinez Child Protection Act (S. 5593, H.R. 10745) would bar removals and findings based solely on a parent’s position on gender, but would not require agencies to track these cases.

If you or someone you know is struggling or in crisis, call or text 988 to reach the 988 Suicide & Crisis Lifeline.

Sources

The FAN Briefing

Don’t miss the next one.

Every Monday: the week’s CPS and foster care investigations, court rulings and what families can do. Plus alerts when we report on a case you follow.

Free. Unsubscribe anytime. See our Privacy Policy.

Related Coverage

More FAN investigations →
What you can do

Don't just read it. Act on it.

Lawmakers fund and oversee this system. Tell California lawmakers what happened here.

Open in my email

Get an email when this case has a new development: charges, court dates, verdicts, settlements. Only about this case; unsubscribe anytime.

Lived through something like this? Your case could be the next one we document.

Read next

This story exists because families spoke up.

Father’s Advocacy Network is a nonprofit newsroom. We don’t take money from the agencies we cover. Help us keep exposing what happens behind closed doors.

About Father’s Advocacy Network. We investigate failures inside CPS, foster care, adoption and family court — and stand with parents fighting to bring their children home. Have a correction or a tip? Contact our newsroom.

Most Read

Is this happening to your family?

Tell us your story — confidentially. Every case we cover starts with a parent speaking up.

Join the conversation

Have something to add? Create a free account or log in to comment. Accounts keep the discussion real and free of bots.

Create free accountLog in

Scroll to Top