Eastland, Texas — A Texas appeals court has thrown out a Brown County jury’s decision to terminate a young couple’s parental rights to their daughter, finding the Department of Family and Protective Services did not prove the child faced a continuing danger at home or that the agency made the reasonable efforts to return her that state law requires. The Eleventh Court of Appeals reversed the March 2026 termination order on Oct. 29 and sent the case back for a new trial. The girl, removed as an infant in January 2024 over concerns about her weight, remains in state custody nearly three years later.
What the court decided
A three-justice panel of the Eleventh Court of Appeals in Eastland, with Justice Trotter writing for Chief Justice Bailey and Justice Williams, held that the evidence supporting two findings Texas law requires before parental rights can be ended was factually insufficient. The case came from the 35th District Court of Brown County.
Under Section 161.001(f) of the Texas Family Code, a court may not terminate parental rights unless the department shows it made reasonable efforts to return the child and that a continuing danger prevents the child’s safe return. The panel found the department fell short on both. It said routine service plans and referrals were not enough given the family’s history, and that the department never explicitly explained to the mother that staying in the same household as the father could lead to losing her daughter.
On continuing danger, the court said the question is whether a present danger in the home prevents return. It found the feeding concerns that triggered the removal were remote, that the child now eats solid food, and that the parents kept a stable home that was clean at the time of trial.
clear and convincing evidence requires more than an expert’s imagination and suspicion.
Eleventh Court of Appeals, In the Interest of R.N., Oct. 29, 2026
The panel reversed the final order, vacated the department’s appointment as permanent managing conservator, reinstated its temporary conservatorship and remanded the case for a new trial on all issues. Proceedings on remand must begin within 180 days of the court’s mandate. Because those findings were missing, the court did not reach the parents’ other arguments, including endangerment, best interest and a strict-scrutiny challenge.
How a feeding concern became a termination case
According to the opinion, the girl was born Oct. 24, 2023, weighing 8 pounds. Her pediatrician diagnosed feeding problems in late November and failure to thrive on Dec. 11, when she was hospitalized for five days. She was hospitalized again on Jan. 3, 2024, for seven days. The parents had also sought a second opinion at Cook Children’s Medical Center, which treated her for acid reflux. The department removed her after she lost about an ounce within 15 hours of her second discharge. Witnesses testified the parents did not keep accurate feeding logs or follow feeding and supervision instructions.
Read nextTexas Parents Tell Lawmakers CPS Still Withholds Medical Records Despite 2025 Law
The cases they buried, read out loud.
New138 Out of 140: The Federal Audit That Caught Arkansas Breaking Its Own Child Abuse Rules
Federal auditors checked 140 Arkansas child abuse investigations and found 138 broke the state's own rules. Families were routinely never told how their cases ended, the state's case system has no place to even…

The child was placed first with her maternal grandmother and later with a foster family in Brownwood. The department approved a monitored return to the parents on July 30, 2025. It lasted 72 days before she was removed again under a writ of attachment and returned to the foster home, where she stayed through trial. The department’s stated goal at trial was termination and adoption by the foster family, though the caseworker testified that adoption was not necessary, according to the opinion.
Genetic findings became central to the case. A Cook Children’s geneticist testified the girl has a serious genetic condition affecting brain development that explains her developmental delays, though not much of her growth delay. A defense expert testified the condition was likely the primary reason for her failure to thrive. The opinion notes the father has the same condition, and that the child reached her lowest weight percentile after she left her parents’ care.
The opinion also addresses the father’s history. As a juvenile, he was referred for conduct involving a younger relative, completed a treatment program and is on the sex offender registry until June 2028. The court found he has no adult convictions and has not reoffended, and that the caseworker testified he was at no higher than average risk. The department did not refer him to offense-specific services. The court called that history remote and not shown to be ongoing.
What the family’s advocates say
The Family Freedom Project, a Texas group advocating for the parents, says hospital staff described the couple as apparently on the autism spectrum, without a formal evaluation, before reporting them to CPS. The group says the department withheld genetic findings from the trial court for almost a year. The appeals court opinion does not address the autism claim, and FAN could not independently verify it.
This case represents a failure of the system at almost every level.
Jeremy Newman, vice president, Family Freedom Project, in The Texan
The Texan reported that the child is in foster care supervised by the contractor 2INgage and that the parents are pursuing a federal civil rights lawsuit alleging disability discrimination. The Family Freedom Project says a federal court ruled in May that CPS and the doctors were immune from suit. The Texan also reported that the parents are asking the appeals court to rescind its new-trial order.
Where the system failed
The appeals court’s findings go to the core of how removals become permanent. The department removed a 2-month-old girl after she lost about an ounce in the hours after a hospital discharge, then spent nearly three years building a case toward adoption by the foster family while a medical explanation for the child’s slow growth came into focus. A jury ended the parents’ rights on a record that an appellate court has now found could not meet the state’s own legal standard. Each month a child spends apart from her parents in a case like this is time no later ruling can return, and nothing in the ruling holds anyone accountable for the delay.
Families facing a petition to end parental rights can read FAN’s guide to termination of parental rights, including the findings the state must prove and how appeals work. FAN is not a law firm and does not give legal advice.
Key facts
- The Eleventh Court of Appeals reversed a Brown County order terminating parental rights on Oct. 29, 2026, and ordered a new trial.
- The court found factually insufficient evidence of reasonable efforts to return the child and of a continuing danger in the home.
- The girl was removed in January 2024 after losing about an ounce within 15 hours of a hospital discharge.
- A monitored return home in 2025 lasted 72 days before she was removed again.
- Expert testimony linked her slow growth in part to a genetic condition; she reached her lowest weight percentile in state care.
- The department’s temporary conservatorship was reinstated; a new trial must start within 180 days of the mandate.
Sources
- Texas Eleventh Court of Appeals — In the Interest of R.N., a Child, No. 11-26-00135-CV (opinion) (2026-10-29)
- The Texan — Appeals Court Overturns Trial in CPS Case of Baby ‘Rose’ Removed from Texas Parents (2026-11-12)
- Family Freedom Project — CPS took their baby for two years after parents labeled “on the autistic spectrum” (2026-11-11)
Don’t miss the next one.
Every Monday: the week’s CPS and foster care investigations, court rulings and what families can do. Plus alerts when we report on a case you follow.
Free. Unsubscribe anytime. See our Privacy Policy.
Related Coverage
TexasTexas CPS Took Grieving Parents’ Toddler Using an Autopsy Report That Didn’t Exist: SuitOct 14, 2026
TexasTexas Seeks to End 15 Years of Foster Care Oversight as Monitors Warn of AbuseNov 6, 2026
TexasTexas Asks Judge to End Foster Care Oversight While Admitting 7 Court Orders UnmetOct 21, 2026
TexasTexas Cut Off a Foster-Care Contractor After Auditors Found Missing Visits and Financial ControlsNov 8, 2026Don't just read it. Act on it.
Lawmakers fund and oversee this system. Tell Texas lawmakers what happened here.
Get an email when this case has a new development: charges, court dates, verdicts, settlements. Only about this case; unsubscribe anytime.
Lived through something like this? Your case could be the next one we document.
ABUSE IN CAREUp nextTexas Seeks to End 15 Years of Foster Care Oversight as Monitors Warn of AbuseTexas told a federal court it spent $320 million on foster-care reforms and should be freed from 15 years of oversight, as monitors still warn it places kids…
Nov 6, 2026
GAL MISCONDUCTCommentary: Too Young to Vote, Old Enough to Pick a Parent. Why Does the System Trust What Children Want?Nov 19, 2026
GAL MISCONDUCTGeorgia’s Age-14 Rule: When a Teenager Can Choose a Parent, and What Parents Need to KnowNov 19, 2026
LAWSUITFrom the Archive: NH Paid $2.25M After Suit Cited 17 Reports on Harmony MontgomeryNov 18, 2026


















